INVESTIGATIVE FRONT-PAGE SPECIAL REPORT | 3 NOVEMBER 2026
Ejimakor challenges the legal foundation of Nnamdi Kanu's conviction, raising questions about jurisdiction, double jeopardy, repealed legislation, evidence, fair hearing and judicial conduct. The critical question is whether the conviction can withstand constitutional scrutiny.
Nigeria's prosecution of Mazi Nnamdi Kanu has once again entered the centre of a major constitutional debate.
This time, the challenge comes from his lawyer, Barrister Aloy Ejimakor, who, in a statement dated 2 November 2026, identified twelve alleged defects in the proceedings that resulted in Kanu's conviction.
These are not minor complaints about courtroom procedure. They concern some of the most fundamental safeguards in Nigerian criminal law: the right to know the precise allegation, the right to a fair hearing, the jurisdiction of the court, the admissibility of evidence and the requirement that guilt must be established beyond reasonable doubt.
But there is an important distinction: a lawyer's identification of alleged errors does not automatically nullify a conviction. Each allegation must be tested against the actual charges, trial record, applicable legislation and judgment of the court.
The implications, however, deserve serious public examination.
THE TWELVE LEGAL QUESTIONS BEFORE THE COURT OF APPEAL
1. Were the charges sufficiently precise to satisfy the Constitution?
Section 36(6)(a) of the 1999 Constitution guarantees every accused person the right to be informed, promptly and in detail, of the nature of the offence.
Ejimakor's argument is that the prosecution relied on broadcasts allegedly made in furtherance of terrorism without sufficiently identifying the specific criminal acts that constituted the offences.
This raises an important legal question: can a person be convicted for terrorism-related conduct without the prosecution clearly identifying the criminal ingredients of the offence and demonstrating how the accused's conduct satisfied them?
The prosecution's answer is that the seven-count charge identified the alleged offences and the statutory provisions under which Kanu was prosecuted. The trial judge accepted that the prosecution had established the charges.
The appellate court must therefore examine the actual wording of each count, the evidence presented and whether the accused had adequate notice of the case against him.
2. Was the prosecution guilty of double jeopardy?
Section 36(9) of the Constitution prohibits trying a person again for an offence, or an offence with the same ingredients, after conviction or acquittal by a competent court, except where a superior court orders otherwise.
This argument requires careful examination of the earlier proceedings.
In October 2022, the Court of Appeal ruled in Kanu's favour, striking out the then-pending charges following its finding concerning his extraordinary rendition from Kenya.
However, the Supreme Court subsequently overturned the Court of Appeal's decision in December 2023 and restored the prosecution's ability to proceed.
Consequently, the existence of the earlier Court of Appeal judgment alone does not establish double jeopardy. The defence must demonstrate that the constitutional prohibition applies notwithstanding the Supreme Court's subsequent intervention.
This is a question the appellate court must confront directly. LawCare Nigeria +2
3. Was Kanu's absence from Nigeria unfairly used against him?
The military invasion of Kanu's family residence in September 2017 and his subsequent departure from Nigeria remain central to the history of this case.
The defence maintains that his departure was connected to the military operation and the danger he faced.
The prosecution, however, has argued that his absence interrupted the proceedings and that he subsequently returned to Nigeria through extraordinary rendition from Kenya.
The legal issue is whether the trial court properly distinguished between the circumstances surrounding his departure and the evidence required to establish the criminal charges.
An accused person's absence from a country cannot, by itself, establish guilt.
The court must evaluate the admissible evidence rather than substitute assumptions about a defendant's movements for proof of the alleged offences.
4. Was Kanu convicted under a repealed Customs law?
Major statutory question
This is one of the most important issues raised in the latest challenge.
Count Seven concerned the alleged importation of a radio transmitter concealed among household goods.
The trial judge relied on Section 47 of the Customs and Excise Management Act in determining that count.
The Nigeria Customs Service Act 2023 repealed the earlier Customs and Excise Management Act. The defence therefore argues that the court could not simply rely on the repealed legislation without addressing the legal consequences of that repeal.
The prosecution's position and the trial court's reasoning must be examined against the applicable saving provisions, the date of the alleged offence and the date the prosecution commenced.
The appellate court must answer:
- Was the relevant offence preserved under the new legislation?
- Did the applicable transitional provisions preserve the prosecution?
- Was the defendant properly charged under an enforceable written law?
- Were the statutory ingredients and applicable penalty properly established?
The fact that a law has been repealed does not automatically extinguish every prosecution commenced under it. The effect depends on the repeal and saving provisions.
But neither can a court convict someone under a provision without establishing that the law remained applicable.
Premium Times Nigeria +2
5. Did the court rely on hearsay evidence?
The defence alleges that the court relied on second-hand accounts concerning killings, sit-at-home enforcement and attacks attributed to IPOB members.
This raises a fundamental question under the Evidence Act.
A criminal conviction must rest on admissible and credible evidence. A witness repeating what another person allegedly witnessed does not automatically establish the truth of the underlying allegation.
However, not every account involving information from another person is inadmissible. The court must distinguish between admissible direct evidence, properly admitted documentary or electronic evidence, relevant circumstantial evidence and inadmissible hearsay.
The appellate court should examine the testimony of each prosecution witness and identify which evidence actually connected Kanu to the alleged offences.
6. Did Nigeria establish jurisdiction over alleged broadcasts made outside the country?
This is a serious question involving territorial and extraterritorial criminal jurisdiction.
Some of the broadcasts attributed to Kanu were allegedly made while he was outside Nigeria.
The defence argues that the prosecution failed to establish where the broadcasts originated and whether the relevant legal conditions for prosecuting conduct committed abroad were satisfied.
The prosecution's case, however, included allegations that broadcasts were received in Nigeria and were intended to intimidate the population.
The court must examine the relevant provisions of the terrorism legislation, the location of the alleged conduct, the location of its consequences and the statutory requirements governing extraterritorial jurisdiction.
The issue is not simply whether a broadcast crossed an international boundary. It is whether Nigerian law authorised the prosecution on the facts established in court.
7. Was there sufficient evidence linking Kanu to specific acts of violence?
This question goes to the heart of criminal responsibility.
The defence maintains that there was no direct forensic evidence, firearm, ballistic evidence or other physical proof connecting Kanu personally to particular violent attacks.
But the absence of a recovered weapon does not automatically defeat a terrorism prosecution.
Under Nigerian criminal law, relevant offences may be established through direct evidence, circumstantial evidence, documentary evidence and properly authenticated electronic evidence.
The decisive issue is whether the prosecution proved every ingredient of each offence beyond reasonable doubt.
The trial judge reportedly relied on broadcasts and directives attributed to Kanu and concluded that they incited attacks against security personnel and civilians.
Reuters also reported that the prosecution's case involved alleged directives and broadcasts connected to deadly attacks in southeastern Nigeria. Reuters +1
The appellate court must determine whether those materials proved the statutory offences or whether the trial court drew conclusions beyond what the evidence could reasonably support.
8. Could allegations from previously struck-out counts influence the conviction?
The defence argues that allegations from counts previously struck out were improperly revived in the judgment.
This raises an important distinction between a count being struck out and the admissibility of evidence relating to conduct mentioned in that count.
The Court of Appeal in 2022 struck out several counts in the earlier proceedings. But the Supreme Court subsequently intervened, and the later trial proceeded under a seven-count charge.
The question is therefore not simply whether an allegation appeared in an earlier struck-out count.
The question is whether the trial judge relied on matters that were legally irrelevant, inadmissible or outside the charges on which Kanu was ultimately tried.
A court cannot convict an accused person for an offence that was never properly charged and established.
9. Were preliminary objections properly determined?
The defence contends that important objections challenging the jurisdiction and competence of the proceedings remained unresolved when judgment was delivered.
This is particularly important because jurisdiction is fundamental to the authority of a court.
A court cannot assume jurisdiction merely because a prosecution has commenced before it.
However, the trial judge reportedly stated that the objections would be determined in the final judgment. The court must therefore examine whether the judgment actually addressed them and whether its conclusions were legally adequate.
The existence of an objection does not automatically invalidate a trial. What matters is whether the objection was properly considered and determined.
10. Was Kanu denied his right to a final address?
Fair hearing question
Section 36 of the Constitution protects the right to a fair hearing.
The defence says Kanu was denied the opportunity to file a final written address before judgment.
But the trial proceedings contain an important complication.
According to reports of the proceedings, Kanu dismissed his legal team and elected to conduct his defence himself. The judge repeatedly gave him opportunities to open his defence, but he declined.
The trial judge subsequently held that Kanu had waived his opportunity to present a defence and directed that neither side would file final written addresses.
The judge's position was that allowing the prosecution, represented by lawyers, to file an address while Kanu, then representing himself, did not would create an imbalance.
The appellate question is whether this procedure was consistent with the constitutional requirements of fair hearing and the applicable criminal procedure rules.
A defendant cannot be forced to defend himself. Equally, a court must ensure that the decision to proceed without a defence is a genuine and legally valid waiver.
guardian.ng +1
11. Was the evidence supporting Count One sufficient?
The defence specifically challenges the evidential foundation of Count One.
The allegation concerned a broadcast allegedly made by Kanu with the intention of intimidating the population.
The prosecution was required to establish the relevant ingredients of the offence, including the prohibited conduct and the necessary criminal intent.
The court must determine whether the prosecution's witnesses, recordings and other admitted evidence established those ingredients beyond reasonable doubt.
There is a distinction between proving that a person made a controversial political statement and proving that the statement constituted a criminal offence under the applicable terrorism legislation.
That distinction is essential to protecting both national security and constitutional freedom of expression.
12. Did the circumstances surrounding judgment compromise the appearance of fair hearing?
The final allegation concerns the courtroom confrontation on 20 November 2025.
Reports indicate that Kanu objected to the commencement of judgment, insisting that he had not been allowed to submit a final written address. The judge ordered him removed from the courtroom after the confrontation escalated.
The question is whether the proceedings that followed were conducted in compliance with the constitutional guarantee of an impartial hearing.
A judge must retain control of the courtroom. Equally, an accused person must be afforded the protections guaranteed by the Constitution.
The appellate court must examine the complete proceedings, not merely the dramatic events captured in media reports.
A courtroom confrontation does not automatically establish judicial bias. But the circumstances surrounding the removal of an accused person and the subsequent delivery of judgment deserve judicial scrutiny.
TheCable +2
WHAT THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT MUST ANSWER
The Federal Government cannot answer these allegations merely by insisting that Kanu was convicted by a court of competent jurisdiction.
It must defend the legal foundation of the conviction.
Its prosecution team, led by the Attorney-General of the Federation's representatives, must be prepared to address several central questions:
- What precise statutory provisions supported each of the seven convictions?
- How did the prosecution satisfy the requirements of the applicable terrorism legislation?
- What evidence established Kanu's personal criminal responsibility?
- How did the court resolve the objections concerning the 2017 military operation and subsequent rendition?
- Why were the preliminary objections considered sufficient to proceed to judgment?
- What legal provisions justified the decision not to receive final written addresses?
- What was the legal effect of the repeal of the Customs and Excise Management Act?
These questions are not an invitation to excuse violence or disregard the suffering of victims of insecurity.
They are questions about whether the Nigerian state followed its own laws while prosecuting a citizen.
THE SUPREME COURT AND THE 2022 COURT OF APPEAL DECISION: AN IMPORTANT DISTINCTION
One issue that must not be misrepresented in public discussion is the earlier extraordinary-rendition litigation.
The Court of Appeal ruled in October 2022 that the earlier proceedings could not stand following Kanu's unlawful rendition from Kenya.
However, the Supreme Court overturned that decision in December 2023, holding that the unlawful manner in which Kanu was brought back did not automatically extinguish Nigeria's power to prosecute him.
This distinction matters.
The Supreme Court's decision did not establish that every subsequent step in the trial was necessarily flawless. Equally, the 2022 Court of Appeal decision cannot simply be presented as an existing acquittal that automatically bars the later prosecution.
The new appeal must be decided on the applicable law and the actual trial record. LawCare Nigeria +1
WHERE DOES THE CASE STAND?
Appeal pending in the reported proceedings
Kanu's conviction was delivered on 20 November 2025 by Justice James Omotosho of the Federal High Court, Abuja.
On 4 February 2026, Kanu filed a notice of appeal containing 22 grounds challenging his conviction and sentences.
According to his lawyer, the appeal proceeded through the compilation and transmission of the record of proceedings, followed by the process of exchanging legal briefs.
The appeal seeks to have the convictions and sentences set aside and Kanu discharged and acquitted. The appellate court could also dismiss the appeal or order a retrial, depending on its findings and the applicable law.
The 12 arguments attributed to Ejimakor on 2 November 2026 should therefore be understood as additional legal criticisms, not as a judgment already delivered by the Court of Appeal. Lawyer +2
THE BIGGER QUESTION: CAN NIGERIA FIGHT TERRORISM WITHOUT WEAKENING THE CONSTITUTION?
This case goes beyond Nnamdi Kanu.
It concerns the relationship between national security, individual liberty, judicial independence and the rule of law.
Nigeria has suffered enormously from insecurity. Families have lost loved ones. Communities have been attacked. Businesses have been destroyed. Security personnel have been killed. The victims deserve justice.
But justice cannot be selective.
If a citizen is accused of terrorism, the prosecution must establish the offence under a valid written law. If evidence is presented, it must satisfy the Evidence Act. If jurisdiction is challenged, the court must determine the issue. If the Constitution guarantees a defence, that guarantee must be respected.
These safeguards are not privileges reserved for popular or innocent defendants. They are protections that apply even to people accused of the most serious crimes.
The same constitutional standards must apply whether the accused is a separatist, a bandit, a terrorist suspect, a political opponent or a powerful government official.
The rule of law is tested most seriously when the person standing in the dock is unpopular, controversial or politically inconvenient.
THE EDITORIAL POSITION: LET THE APPEAL ANSWER THE QUESTIONS
Nigeria must not confuse the prosecution of separatist agitation with the abandonment of constitutional obligations.
Neither should the defence confuse allegations of procedural irregularity with automatic proof that the accused is innocent.
The proper place to resolve these competing claims is the appellate court.
If the conviction is legally sound, the prosecution should be able to defend it against every properly raised ground of appeal.
If fundamental errors are established, the appellate court must be prepared to correct them, even if the consequences are politically uncomfortable.
There must be no sacred prosecution, no untouchable defendant and no special constitution for politically sensitive cases.
The victims of violence deserve justice. The accused deserves a fair trial. The Nigerian public deserves confidence that its courts administer justice according to law.
A conviction must be sustained by evidence and law, not by the political sensitivity of the defendant or the public pressure surrounding the case.
And if the legal foundation is defective, the appropriate judicial remedy must follow.
That is what separates constitutional democracy from government by power.
DOCUMENTS AND SOURCES FOR FURTHER INVESTIGATION
The following materials are particularly important for journalists, lawyers and researchers examining the case:
- TheCable – Full text of the judgment sentencing Nnamdi Kanu.
- Full Federal High Court judgment – Count Seven and Customs law.
- Channels Television – Kanu's 22 grounds of appeal, 4 February 2026.
- TVC News – Ejimakor explains the appeal process, 9 April 2026.
- Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act 2022 – transitional provisions.
- Section 36 of the 1999 Constitution – fair hearing and fundamental rights.
- The Guardian – proceedings concerning the closure of Kanu's defence.
EDITORIAL VERIFICATION NOTE
The precise 12-point statement attributed to Ejimakor on 2 November 2026 has not been independently authenticated against its original publication in the sources retrieved. This article examines the supplied allegations against available court reporting and legal materials. The original statement and certified trial record should be obtained before publication as a fully documented investigative report.
Suggested newspaper headline: TWELVE QUESTIONS, ONE CONVICTION: WILL NIGERIA'S COURT OF APPEAL UPHOLD OR OVERTURN THE KANU JUDGMENT?