13 min read

THE DAY NIGERIA'S FEDERALISM COLLAPSED: DID TAFAWA BALEWA'S INTERVENTION IN THE ACTION GROUP CRISIS SET THE FIRST REPUBLIC ON THE ROAD TO DESTRUCTION?

Worked for 30s

HISTORICAL INVESTIGATION | NIGERIA'S FIRST REPUBLIC | 1962–1966

The removal of a regional Premier became a national constitutional confrontation. The Federal Government intervened, Parliament declared a state of emergency, the Western Region lost its elected political leadership, and the country's democratic institutions suffered a major blow. But who was constitutionally right, who exercised federal power, and what did the courts actually decide?

The crisis of 1962 deserves a much more prominent place in Nigeria's teaching of constitutional history. It was not merely a quarrel between Obafemi Awolowo and Samuel Ladoke Akintola. It exposed the dangerous consequences of political factionalism, partisan policing, disputed constitutional powers and federal intervention in regional government.

And there is an important historical irony: the man who presided over the Federal Government's intervention, Prime Minister Abubakar Tafawa Balewa, would himself be killed in the military coup of January 1966.

However, the historical record requires us to separate documented events from political interpretations. The distinction is essential if this investigation is to withstand scrutiny.

1. THE CRISIS DID NOT BEGIN WITH BALEWA: IT BEGAN INSIDE THE ACTION GROUP

To understand May 1962, we must return to the political disagreement between Chief Obafemi Awolowo and his former deputy, Chief Samuel Ladoke Akintola.

Awolowo had left the Western Region premiership to become Leader of the Opposition in the Federal Parliament. Akintola succeeded him as Premier.

But the two men increasingly disagreed over political strategy, the direction of the Action Group and the relationship the party should maintain with the Northern People's Congress (NPC), which controlled the Federal Government.

Akintola's political relationship with the NPC leadership became a source of serious suspicion among Awolowo's supporters.

At the Action Group's 1962 convention in Jos, the disagreement escalated. Akintola and his supporters walked out. The party subsequently removed him as Deputy Leader and demanded that he resign as Premier.

On 21 May 1962, Governor Sir Adesoji Aderemi removed Akintola and appointed Alhaji Dauda Soroye Adegbenro.

This was not simply an arbitrary party announcement. The Action Group faction supporting Adegbenro argued that it had the parliamentary majority required to withdraw confidence from Akintola.

However, Akintola disputed the constitutional procedure and challenged his removal.

The important point is that removing someone from a party leadership position and removing that person from the constitutional office of Premier were two different legal questions.

The distinction became the subject of litigation. securityanddevelopment.org +2

2. WHAT DID THE PRIVY COUNCIL ACTUALLY DECIDE?

This is one of the most important corrections to the circulating account.

The case was Adegbenro v Akintola and Aderemi, decided by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council on 27 May 1963.

The original Western Region constitutional provision stated that the Governor could remove the Premier if it appeared to him that the Premier no longer commanded the support of a majority of the House of Assembly.

The Privy Council interpreted that provision in Adegbenro's favour.

The Federal Supreme Court had earlier ruled against the removal, but the Privy Council reversed that decision.

Primary case reference: Adegbenro v Akintola [1963] UKPC 15.

But there is another chapter that must not be omitted.

On 27 May 1963, the Western Region enacted an amendment to its Constitution, subsequently ratified by the Federal Parliament, requiring a majority resolution of the House of Assembly before the Governor could remove a Premier on that ground. The amendment was made retrospective to 2 October 1960.

In October 1963, the Nigerian Supreme Court considered the implications of that amendment in the subsequent proceedings. The legal position was therefore more complicated than the claim that the Privy Council simply settled the entire political dispute forever.

The lesson is that the original constitutional dispute, the Privy Council judgment and the subsequent retrospective amendment must be read together. LawCare Nigeria +2

3. THE POLICE QUESTION: WHO CONTROLLED THE INSTRUMENT OF FORCE?

Hon. Members Escaping From The Western House Of Assembly Crisis In 1962 - Pics - Politics - Nigeria
PENGlobal Associates Limited
Chief Obafemi Awolowo

This is arguably the most consequential institutional issue raised by the account.

Nigeria's police force was federally controlled, rather than an independent police service answerable to each regional government.

That arrangement created a fundamental problem in a federation where regional governments had their own political mandates but depended on a centrally controlled police institution to maintain law and order.

Historian Amusa Saheed Balogun examined this problem in a 2013 article published in the Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria, titled:

An Assessment of the Partisan Role of the Nigeria Police Force in the 1962 Action Group Crisis.

His research documented allegations and evidence of partisan policing during the crisis. It examined how the police became entangled in the rivalry between the Akintola and Awolowo factions.

This is significant because a federal police force should protect the constitutional order, not become an instrument for determining which political faction governs a region. ResearchGate +1

The circulating account gives a particularly specific narrative: that Western Region Police Commissioner Emmanuel Olufemi Olufunwa pledged allegiance to Adegbenro on 22 May, only to receive an instruction from Inspector-General Sir John Ernest Hodge to withdraw that allegiance.

That precise exchange requires corroboration from contemporary police records, correspondence or reliable eyewitness documentation. The scholarly research establishes the broader problem of police partisanship, but I would not present that particular conversation as independently proven.

The constitutional question remains important: could a regional Premier effectively exercise executive authority if the police operating in his region took their operational direction from a federal command structure aligned with his political opponents?

That is a question about the architecture of Nigerian federalism, not merely about two politicians.

4. 29 MAY 1962: BALEWA TAKES THE CRISIS TO THE FEDERAL PARLIAMENT

Nigeria’s 1st Republic: (1960–1966) – Independence, Leaders & Legacy

This is where the dispute moved from the Western Region into the heart of Nigeria's federal government.

On 29 May 1962, Prime Minister Tafawa Balewa moved a resolution under Section 65 of the 1960 Federal Constitution declaring a state of public emergency in Western Nigeria.

His proposed resolution stated that the emergency would remain in force until the end of December 1962.

The Prime Minister defended his action on the grounds that Western Nigeria had been without a properly constituted government and that the political confrontation threatened peace and public order.

His parliamentary speech is preserved in A Selection of Speeches Made by Alhaji the Right Honourable Sir Abubakar Tafawa Balewa.

There is an important admission in that speech: Balewa acknowledged that the Governor had removed Akintola and appointed Adegbenro, while Akintola had challenged the removal in court. Wikisource, the free online library +1

The resolution passed by Parliament, according to historian Amusa Saheed Balogun's research, received:

  • House of Representatives: 209 votes in favour and 36 against.
  • Senate: 32 votes in favour, seven against and two abstentions.

This was not simply an executive order issued by Balewa without parliamentary involvement. It was a federal parliamentary declaration initiated by his government.

But the consequences were enormous.

The Federal Government appointed Dr Moses Adekoyejo Majekodunmi, then Federal Minister of Health, as Administrator of Western Nigeria.

The elected regional government was suspended.

Leading political figures from the rival factions, including Awolowo, Akintola and Adegbenro, faced movement restrictions.

The very politicians whose disagreement had produced the crisis were now subject to federal emergency administration. ResearchGate +2

The fundamental constitutional question was no longer simply who was the Premier. It was whether the Federal Government's emergency powers could justifiably suspend the political institutions of an entire region because of a crisis involving its ruling party and legislature.

5. THE COURT RECORD: A CRITICAL DETAIL THAT MUST NOT BE HIDDEN

The case of Adegbenro v Attorney-General of the Federation and Others is particularly revealing.

Adegbenro challenged the emergency arrangements and sought to prevent the Administrator from exercising the powers of the suspended regional government.

His affidavit made a remarkable allegation.

He said that, apart from disturbances inside the House of Assembly, there had been no public disturbance or civil commotion in Western Nigeria.

He also reported that the only incident brought to his attention by the police after his appointment was that Chief Akintola had broken through the door of the Premier's office.

He further stated that the Commissioner of Police had access to him but had never suggested that civil commotion was imminent or that public tranquillity was threatened.

These were Adegbenro's sworn allegations, not findings independently established by the court. LawCare Nigeria

The Federal Supreme Court, presided over by Chief Justice Adetokunbo Ademola, refused the interlocutory injunction.

Its reasoning deserves careful attention. The court stated that it was unnecessary to decide whether a declaration made in bad faith could be invalidated because it was impossible to say that there was no ground to justify the declaration in the circumstances before it.

This was not a judicial finding that every action of the Federal Government was proper, nor was it a blanket endorsement of partisan policing.

It was a decision on the application before the court.

That distinction matters enormously.

A government can possess a constitutional power and still raise legitimate questions about the purpose, proportionality and manner in which it exercises that power. LawCare Nigeria +1

6. THE 1953 WARNING: WHAT OLIVER LYTTELTON SAID ABOUT NIGERIAN FEDERALISM

NPG x157766; Oliver Lyttelton, 1st Viscount Chandos - Portrait - National Portrait Gallery

The circulating article quotes British Colonial Secretary Oliver Lyttelton's statement of 21 May 1953.

The quotation is substantially accurate.

In the British House of Commons, Lyttelton acknowledged that Nigeria's three regions could not work effectively under an excessively closely knit federation.

He declared that the Constitution should be redrawn to provide:

  • Greater regional autonomy.
  • Removal of central powers of intervention in matters properly within regional competence.
  • A continuing central organisation to protect common economic and defence interests.

The original Hansard record confirms this statement. api.parliament.uk +1

There is, however, a qualification.

Lyttelton was speaking in the context of the constitutional negotiations following the 1953 political crisis, not issuing a binding constitutional prohibition against all future federal intervention.

Nevertheless, his statement captures an important principle of federalism: matters that can be managed independently by constituent regions should not automatically be transferred to the central government.

The 1962 crisis provides a useful test of whether Nigeria's political leadership respected that principle.

7. DID NIGERIA ABOLISH PRIVY COUNCIL APPEALS TO PUNISH AWOLOWO?

This allegation needs correction.

Nigeria abolished appeals to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council when the Republican Constitution came into force on 1 October 1963.

The constitutional change was part of Nigeria's transition from a constitutional monarchy to a republic, with a Nigerian President replacing the British monarch as Head of State.

The abolition was not an action uniquely directed at Awolowo.

The British parliamentary proceedings on the Nigeria Republic Bill expressly explained the new constitutional arrangement and the treatment of pending appeals. UK Parliament +2

There is also a revealing chronological point: the Privy Council had already delivered its Adegbenro judgment on 27 May 1963, months before the Republican Constitution came into force.

Therefore, the claim that Nigeria hurriedly abolished Privy Council appeals specifically to frustrate Awolowo is not supported by the constitutional record.

The legitimate question is whether Nigeria's new Supreme Court would develop sufficient independence and authority to protect constitutional government. That is a separate question from the motive attributed to the abolition.

8. FROM EMERGENCY RULE TO THE IMPRISONMENT OF AWOLOWO

The consequences of the 1962 intervention did not end when the six-month emergency period expired.

The Federal Government subsequently returned Akintola to the premiership under a new political arrangement, associated with the United People's Party, rather than restoring the original Action Group administration.

Awolowo and several Action Group leaders were subsequently prosecuted in connection with an alleged plot to overthrow the Federal Government.

In 1963, Awolowo was convicted of treasonable felony and sentenced to ten years' imprisonment.

A Coker Commission of Inquiry was also established to investigate the financial administration of Western Region statutory corporations.

Its findings became another major source of political controversy. The commission reported serious financial irregularities involving public corporations and the Action Group. Those findings should be examined separately from the constitutional controversy surrounding the emergency declaration. securityanddevelopment.org +2

This sequence raises an uncomfortable question about the use of state institutions:

When a ruling political coalition becomes involved in a regional political conflict, how can the public be confident that federal police, emergency powers, commissions of inquiry and criminal prosecutions are being used impartially?

That question is still relevant to Nigeria.

9. DID THE ACTION GROUP CRISIS CAUSE THE JANUARY 1966 COUP?

Nigeria's First Coup: The midnight massacre that altered the nation’s history | Pulse Nigeria
Ahmadu Bello, 1962
Samuel L. Akintola – People and Organizations – The John F. Kennedy Presidential Library & Museum

On 15 January 1966, the First Republic was overthrown in a military coup.

Among those killed were:

  • Sir Abubakar Tafawa Balewa, Prime Minister.
  • Sir Ahmadu Bello, Premier of Northern Nigeria.
  • Chief Samuel Ladoke Akintola, Premier of Western Nigeria.
  • Chief Festus Okotie-Eboh, Federal Minister of Finance.

The military intervention terminated Nigeria's First Republic.

But it would be historically inaccurate to claim that the 1962 Action Group crisis alone caused the coup.

Several developments contributed to the collapse:

  • The Action Group split and the Western Region emergency.
  • Awolowo's imprisonment and the weakening of opposition politics.
  • The controversial 1962 and 1963 censuses.
  • The disputed 1964 federal elections.
  • The controversial October 1965 Western Region elections.
  • Political violence, intimidation and the breakdown of confidence in democratic institutions.
  • The intervention of military officers who organised the January 1966 coup.

The 1965 Western Region election crisis and the violence popularly associated with Operation Wetie were particularly destructive.

The coup therefore emerged from a much wider national crisis involving political parties, regional competition, disputed elections, institutional weaknesses and military intervention.

Historian Richard Sklar's examination of the January coup also places it within the wider struggle over Nigeria's regional and national political balance. Cambridge Core +3

The July 1966 counter-coup, the subsequent mass killings, the declaration of the Republic of Biafra in 1967 and the Nigerian Civil War were further developments with their own immediate causes.

They cannot responsibly be attributed to one decision made in May 1962.

However, the weakening of constitutional institutions during the First Republic forms an important part of the background to those subsequent events.

10. THE BIGGER QUESTION: WAS NIGERIA'S FEDERALISM ALREADY COMPROMISED?

The central issue exposed by the Action Group crisis was the relationship between political autonomy and federal authority.

Consider the institutional arrangement:

Institution Constitutional position
Western Region Government Responsible for regional administration
Western Region Governor Constitutional authority under the regional constitution
Western Region House of Assembly Legislative institution
Nigeria Police Force Federally controlled
Federal Parliament Exercised federal legislative and emergency powers
Federal Prime Minister Head of the Federal Government

The arrangement contained a structural tension.

Regional governments were expected to govern their territories, but a critical instrument of public order remained under federal control.

The 1962 crisis demonstrated how this arrangement could become politically contentious when regional and federal political interests diverged.

A 2026 academic study of federalism and policing in Nigeria also identifies the 1962 crisis as an example of the vulnerability of a federally controlled police force to political influence. tandfonline.com +1

This is why the history deserves attention in contemporary constitutional debates.

11. THE PROPOSAL FOR SIX AUTONOMOUS ZONES

The original account proposes six autonomous zones, with Abuja retaining responsibility for currency, defence and foreign affairs.

That proposal belongs to the wider Nigerian debate about restructuring.

However, there are constitutional questions that must be answered before such a structure can be implemented.

  • Would the six zones become federating units with their own constitutions?
  • Would they control their police services?
  • Would they collect and administer their own taxes?
  • How would oil and mineral revenues be shared?
  • What would happen to the existing 36 states?
  • Would local governments report to the zones or retain constitutional independence?
  • What powers would remain exclusively with Abuja?
  • How would minority communities within each zone be protected?

There is also a need to distinguish between six geopolitical zones as administrative groupings and six constitutionally autonomous federating units. They are not the same thing.

The experience of 1962 suggests that merely creating new administrative boundaries will not guarantee federalism. The distribution of constitutional powers, fiscal authority, policing and judicial independence matters just as much.

12. THE FINAL HISTORICAL VERDICT: WHAT SHOULD NIGERIAN TEXTBOOKS TEACH?

The Action Group crisis should not be taught as a simplistic story of one innocent political faction and one villainous Prime Minister.

It should teach at least five important lessons.

First: Political parties must respect their own constitutions, but party discipline and constitutional removal from public office are not interchangeable.

Second: Regional political autonomy must be protected by clear constitutional rules, not merely by the goodwill of the Federal Government.

Third: The police must be institutionally insulated from partisan political instructions.

Fourth: Emergency powers must not become convenient instruments for displacing political opponents or suspending democratic institutions without compelling constitutional justification.

Fifth: Courts must be able to adjudicate constitutional disputes independently, even when the parties involved are powerful political actors.

The tragedy of the First Republic was not simply that politicians disagreed. It was that political disagreements increasingly became battles over control of state institutions, elections, security forces and constitutional authority.

That is the historical warning.

THE NEWSPAPER'S EDITORIAL QUESTION

DID TAFAWA BALEWA DESTROY THE FIRST REPUBLIC?

The evidence establishes that Balewa's government played a decisive role in the federal intervention of 29 May 1962. It declared the emergency, suspended the Western Region's elected government and installed a federal administrator.

The evidence also establishes that the Action Group's internal divisions, the Akintola–Awolowo rivalry and violence within the Western legislature preceded that intervention.

It would therefore be unjustified to attribute the entire collapse of the First Republic to Balewa alone.

But his government's decision deserves sustained constitutional scrutiny because it demonstrated how federal emergency powers could be used to displace regional political institutions.

The deeper issue is not whether Balewa personally destroyed Nigeria. It is whether the constitutional arrangements of the First Republic contained sufficient safeguards against political misuse of federal power.

Nigeria must learn from 1962 because a federation cannot survive on paper if its constituent governments cannot exercise their constitutionally assigned responsibilities without political intimidation or arbitrary interference.

HISTORICAL SOURCES AND DOCUMENTS

These are useful starting points for anyone who wants to verify the investigation rather than rely on social-media retellings.

An important outstanding research issue: The precise alleged exchange between Commissioner Olufunwa and Inspector-General Hodge on 22 May 1962 still needs primary documentary corroboration. It should not be published as an established fact without that evidence.

Editorial recommendation: The 1962 Action Group crisis should be included in Nigerian constitutional history alongside the 1953 constitutional crisis, the 1963 Republican Constitution, the 1966 coups and the 1967–1970 Civil War. Its significance extends far beyond the personalities involved. It concerns the very foundations of federalism, democratic accountability and the relationship between the centre and the regions.

6

6

Type at least two letters to search titles, summaries and topics.