4 min read

ONE NIGERIA, TWO STANDARDS?

THE RESOURCE QUESTION THAT CAN NO LONGER BE BURIED

37 MINERS DEAD IN NSCDC CUSTODY: IF NIGERIA OWNS THE RESOURCES, WHO OWNS THE LAW

Nigeria cannot continue to preach one country, one Constitution and one national economy while allowing Nigerians to perceive radically different standards of resource control and law enforcement across the federation.

The deaths of 37 suspected illegal miners in NSCDC custody in Niger State have brought that contradiction brutally to the surface.

The men were arrested during operations against suspected illegal mining. They were subsequently detained by the Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps. Thirty-seven died in custody.

The NSCDC initially suggested a disease outbreak. Survivors, however, described extreme overcrowding and poor ventilation, raising the possibility of suffocation. The Federal Government has now ordered an independent investigation and suspended officers connected with the incident.

The investigation must establish the truth.

But there is a much bigger question behind the tragedy:

WHY DOES NIGERIA INSIST THAT ITS NATURAL RESOURCES BELONG TO THE FEDERATION—AND THEN ALLOW CITIZENS TO PERCEIVE DIFFERENT RULES FOR DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE COUNTRY?

The Constitution is unequivocal on ownership.

Section 44(3) provides that the entire property in and control of minerals, mineral oils and natural gas in Nigeria vest in the Government of the Federation. The Exclusive Legislative List also places mines and minerals, including oil fields and natural gas, under federal jurisdiction.

There should therefore be no northern mineral law and southern petroleum law.

There should be one Nigeria, one federal standard and one law.

Yet this is where Nigerians are increasingly asking uncomfortable questions.

Petroleum from the Niger Delta is treated as a national resource. The Federal Government exercises control over its exploitation, taxation, regulation and security.

When crude oil theft becomes the target, the state deploys sophisticated security operations.

Nobody tells the oil-producing communities:

“The oil beneath your soil belongs exclusively to your region.”

Fine.

Then let the same principle apply to every gold deposit, lithium deposit, uranium deposit and other mineral resource in every part of Nigeria.

NO DOUBLE STANDARD IN RESOURCE CONTROL

If an ordinary young man entering a mine without the appropriate licence is arrested, prosecuted or detained, the law must apply.

But illegal mining cannot become a convenient excuse for selective enforcement.

The government must publish the mining licences.

Who owns them?

Who holds the beneficial interests?

Who finances the operations?

Which companies have exploration and mining rights?

How much mineral leaves each site?

How much royalty is paid?

How much enters the Federation Account?

How much disappears?

These questions are not ethnic questions.

They are questions of public accountability.

And the 37 deaths have made them unavoidable.

THE DEAD CANNOT BE USED TO HIDE THE BIGGER QUESTION

The victims were suspects—not convicted criminals.

Once the Nigerian state arrests a person and puts him in government custody, the state assumes responsibility for his life.

The President himself has said the investigation must examine the circumstances of the arrests, detention conditions, the number detained, medical attention and the events leading to the deaths. He also said that where evidence establishes official responsibility, prosecution should follow.

That is precisely what Nigerians should demand.

Not revenge.
Not ethnic mobilisation.
Not propaganda.
Truth.

If these men died from disease, establish it scientifically.

If they died from suffocation, establish it.

If negligence contributed to their deaths, identify those responsible.

If anyone abused them, prosecute that person.

If the detention facility was dangerously overcrowded, identify who authorised it.

And if there was criminal conduct, let the evidence speak.

BUT HERE IS THE QUESTION THE FEDERATION MUST ANSWER

Why should a federation that claims collective ownership of natural resources not have complete transparency about the exploitation of every natural resource in every region?

Why should Nigerians not know the owners and beneficiaries of major mining operations?

Why should the public not see the revenue generated from gold, lithium and other minerals?

Why should communities in resource-producing areas not know exactly what the Federation collects from their soil?

And why should resource control remain a subject that politicians approach differently depending on whether the resource is petroleum or solid minerals?

Nigeria cannot demand national ownership when discussing oil and then tolerate opacity when discussing solid minerals.

THE BIAFRAN QUESTION WILL NOT DISAPPEAR BY SHOUTING IT DOWN

This is why the resource question increasingly intersects with the Biafran question.

The issue is not whether one ethnic group should be allowed to steal another group's resources.

The issue is whether the Nigerian federation has created a constitutional arrangement in which all peoples genuinely feel that they are equal stakeholders in the country.

If Nigerians in one region believe that their resources are national property while resources elsewhere are effectively controlled through networks of local political and commercial power, that perception must be tested against facts.

If the perception is false, publish the figures and destroy it with evidence.

If it is partly true, correct the system.

If the federation is structurally unfair, reform the federation.

And if a substantial people conclude that the federation cannot provide an equitable political compact, their demand for a peaceful and democratic determination of their political future cannot simply be dismissed as noise.

ONE CONSTITUTION MUST MEAN ONE STANDARD

Nigeria already accommodates different legal traditions, including Sharia Courts of Appeal with constitutionally defined jurisdiction in Islamic personal-law matters. That is different from saying that the entire North operates under Sharia law while the entire South operates under a single alternative legal code.

The real issue is simpler:

Do Nigerians enjoy equal protection of the law?

Do citizens face the same standard of policing?

The same standard of prosecution?

The same standard of resource regulation?

The same standard of transparency?

The same standard of accountability?

That is the test of a federation.

FROM MINNA TO THE NIGER DELTA, THE LAW MUST BE BLIND

The answer to the 37 deaths cannot merely be another committee report that gathers dust.

The country needs a national resource-accountability framework.

Publish every major mining licence.

Publish beneficial ownership.

Publish production figures.

Publish royalties and taxes.

Publish federal receipts.

Publish FAAC treatment of those revenues.

Audit illegal mining enforcement across all regions.

Investigate every death in government custody.

Apply the same law to illegal oil theft and illegal solid-mineral exploitation.

And then let Nigerians see the numbers.

Because there is only one defensible principle:

IF NIGERIA IS ONE COUNTRY, THERE MUST BE ONE STANDARD FOR EVERY NIGERIAN RESOURCE.

The dead 37 deserve justice.

The mining communities deserve the truth.

The oil-producing communities deserve fairness.

Every Nigerian deserves equal protection under the law.

And the federation itself deserves something even more fundamental:

A constitutional arrangement that its citizens can believe is fair.

Until that happens, the resource-control question will continue to return—again and again—no matter how many times politicians attempt to bury it.

The time has come to stop asking Nigerians to believe in one Nigeria merely because the Constitution says so.

Make the federation fair enough for Nigerians to believe in it.

Type at least two letters to search titles, summaries and topics.