5 min read

BAKASSI: THE CASE NIGERIA MUST NOT ALLOW HISTORY TO BURY

GOWON, MAROUA AND THE ICJ: DID NIGERIA'S MILITARY HEAD OF STATE HAVE THE POWER TO BIND THE COUNTRY?

There are some national questions that governments may settle administratively, but history refuses to bury.

Bakassi is one of them.

For years, Nigerians have been told that the International Court of Justice (ICJ) settled the Bakassi question once and for all in favour of Cameroon.

That statement is legally incomplete.

The ICJ delivered its judgment on 10 October 2002, holding that sovereignty over the Bakassi Peninsula lay with Cameroon, principally on the basis of the Anglo-German Agreement of 11 March 1913. The Court also dealt with the maritime boundary and the various instruments relied upon by both countries.

But buried inside that judgment is a constitutional question of enormous importance to Nigeria:

Could General Yakubu Gowon, as Nigeria's military Head of State in 1975, bind the Federal Republic of Nigeria to the Maroua Declaration without ratification or approval by the Supreme Military Council?

That question was not invented after Nigeria lost Bakassi.

Nigeria argued it before the ICJ.

And one of the judges agreed with Nigeria.

THE MAROUA QUESTION

On 1 June 1975, General Yakubu Gowon and Cameroonian President Ahmadou Ahidjo signed the Maroua Declaration, concerning the maritime boundary between the two countries.

Nigeria subsequently challenged its binding force.

The Nigerian argument was straightforward: under the military constitutional arrangement then operating, the Supreme Military Council had the relevant executive authority, and the Maroua Declaration had not received the required approval.

The issue therefore was not simply whether a Nigerian Head of State had put his signature on a document.

The deeper question was:

Did the Nigerian Head of State possess the constitutional authority to make that commitment binding on Nigeria?

That question went directly to the heart of sovereignty.

JUDGE AJIBOLA'S DISSENT

This is where the historical record becomes particularly striking.

Judge ad hoc Bola Ajibola, sitting in the Bakassi case, disagreed with the majority's treatment of the Maroua Declaration.

His dissenting opinion states that in 1975 the Supreme Military Council was the ultimate executive body vested with the power to ratify agreements made by the Head of State.

His conclusion was blunt: the Maroua Declaration had not been ratified by the Supreme Military Council and therefore, in his view, did not have binding force against Nigeria.

He expressly invoked Article 46 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties concerning violation of fundamental internal rules regarding competence to conclude treaties.

This is not a minor footnote.

It means that a member of the Court reached essentially the constitutional conclusion that Nigeria had placed before the Court.

BUT THE MAJORITY DISAGREED

The majority did not accept that argument.

The ICJ ultimately determined Bakassi on the basis of the historical and legal instruments before it, including the 1913 Anglo-German Agreement, and held that sovereignty over Bakassi belonged to Cameroon.

The Court's decision is legally binding.

But a binding judgment does not mean that every legal argument against it was frivolous, nor does it mean that every historical question surrounding the dispute has ceased to deserve examination.

Indeed, the existence of Judge Ajibola's detailed dissent demonstrates that the constitutional question was a genuine legal controversy.

WHAT ABOUT THE CIVIL WAR?

There is another part of the Bakassi story that must be handled with historical discipline.

It has been alleged that Gowon's policy toward Cameroon during the Nigerian Civil War was connected with preventing Biafra from obtaining access to the sea.

That allegation requires documentary evidence before it can responsibly be presented as established historical fact.

What can be established from the ICJ record is that the Maroua Declaration was signed in 1975, five years after the Nigerian Civil War ended in January 1970. Therefore, the 1975 declaration itself cannot accurately be described as a wartime transfer of Bakassi.

The wartime history may nevertheless be relevant to understanding the political circumstances surrounding Nigeria-Cameroon relations and should be investigated through military records, diplomatic correspondence and archival material.

History must be investigated—not manufactured.

CAN NIGERIA APPEAL?

Here the answer is more difficult.

The ICJ is not an ordinary domestic appellate court.

Article 60 of the Statute of the International Court of Justice provides that the Court's judgment is final and without appeal.

Therefore, Nigeria cannot simply file an appeal against the 2002 judgment because it disagrees with it.

There was, however, a procedure for revision.

Article 61 permits revision where a new fact is discovered which:

  • existed when the judgment was delivered;
  • was unknown to the Court and the party seeking revision;
  • is decisive in character; and
  • was not unknown because of negligence.

There is also a strict time limit: an application must be made within six months of discovery of the new fact and, in any event, not after ten years from the judgment.

The ten-year period from 10 October 2002 therefore expired in October 2012.

Consequently, a conventional Article 61 revision application cannot now simply be filed as though the 2002 judgment were an ordinary appeal.

SO IS BAKASSI CLOSED FOREVER?

That is where Nigeria needs serious constitutional and international-law scholarship rather than political slogans.

The first task should be to establish whether there exists any genuinely new decisive fact meeting the stringent requirements of Article 61, rather than attempting to relitigate the same evidence that was already before the Court.

The second task should be to examine whether there are any questions concerning the interpretation or implementation of the judgment that can properly be raised through the mechanisms available under the ICJ Statute.

The third—and perhaps most important—task is historical.

Nigeria should assemble a complete archival record concerning:

Gowon → the Supreme Military Council → Nigeria-Cameroon negotiations → the 1975 Maroua Declaration → subsequent Nigerian objections → the ICJ proceedings → Judge Ajibola's dissent → implementation of the judgment.

Only after that documentary record is assembled can Nigeria determine whether there is a legally viable route for further action.

THE QUESTION WE MUST ASK

The Bakassi story should not be reduced to:

“The ICJ gave Bakassi to Cameroon. End of story.”

The proper question is more profound:

Was every instrument relied upon to determine Nigeria's territorial and maritime obligations validly entered into by the Nigerian authority constitutionally competent to bind the Nigerian State at the time?

That question was placed before the ICJ.

The Court answered it differently from Judge Ajibola.

That disagreement is part of the official judicial record.

And it deserves to be studied again.

BAKASSI MUST BECOME A LESSON IN STATECRAFT

Whatever one's view of the ultimate territorial outcome, Nigeria should draw one permanent lesson from Bakassi:

No government should casually commit the territory, resources or sovereign interests of a nation without an unimpeachable constitutional and legal foundation.

Military governments come and go.

Presidents come and go.

Governors come and go.

But the territory belongs to the Nigerian people and to generations yet unborn.

If a future government believes that the historical record contains evidence capable of supporting further legal action, it should not rely upon newspaper rhetoric or political declarations.

It should commission an independent panel of Nigerian constitutional lawyers, international-law experts, historians, archivists and boundary specialists.

Let them answer, document by document:

What was signed?

Who had authority to sign it?

What required ratification?

What was ratified?

What was not ratified?

What did Nigeria tell Cameroon at the time?

What evidence was before the ICJ?

What evidence was unavailable?

What did the majority decide?

What precisely did Judge Ajibola reject?

And finally:

IS THERE ANY LEGALLY AVAILABLE DOOR THAT REMAINS OPEN?

If the answer is no, Nigeria will at least have established the historical truth.

If the answer is yes, Nigeria should pursue that avenue through law—not through war, threats or emotion.

Because Bakassi is not merely a piece of land on a map.

It is a lesson about sovereignty, constitutional authority, military government, international law and the permanent consequences of decisions taken by temporary rulers.

Nigeria owes its citizens nothing less than the complete truth.

Type at least two letters to search titles, summaries and topics.