HOW MANY MORE NIGERIANS MUST DIE BEFORE THE GOVERNMENT CONFRONTS RELIGIOUS EXTREMISM, DEFENDS THE RIGHT TO LIFE AND ALLOWS AN HONEST NATIONAL DEBATE ABOUT PEACEFUL SELF-DETERMINATION?
By Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic A June 12 Legislator
There comes a time in the history of every nation when silence ceases to be neutrality and becomes an abdication of responsibility.
For Nigeria, that time has long arrived.
A disturbing video circulating in public discourse raises allegations of a woman being brutally murdered after converting to Christianity. The account alleges that a religious cleric mobilised men to attack her inside her own home.
The victim, location, date and alleged perpetrators have not yet been independently established from the material available. These allegations must therefore be treated as matters requiring urgent criminal investigation, not as proven facts.
But the constitutional question they raise is beyond dispute.
Since when did changing one's religion become a death sentence in the Federal Republic of Nigeria?
Who gave any religious leader the authority to determine who should live and who should die?
And where are the police, the Department of State Services, the Attorney-General of the Federation and the President when credible threats of religiously motivated violence emerge?
Nigeria cannot continue to describe itself as a constitutional democracy while citizens fear that exercising their fundamental freedoms could expose them to murder.
THE OWO MASSACRE: WHEN WORSHIPPERS BECAME TARGETS
On Sunday, 5 June 2022, worshippers gathered at St. Francis Catholic Church in Owo, Ondo State, to celebrate Pentecost.
They came to pray.
They did not come to fight a war.
Yet terrorists attacked the congregation with explosives and firearms, killing more than 40 people and injuring many others.
Fathers, mothers, children and other innocent worshippers became victims of an atrocity that shocked the country.
On 3 June 2026, the Federal High Court in Abuja convicted four men of terrorism offences connected with the massacre and sentenced them to death. A fifth defendant was acquitted.
The court accepted evidence linking the convicted men to a terrorist cell identified in the proceedings as Al-Shabaab.
That judgment is significant.
It demonstrates that Nigeria possesses legal institutions capable of investigating and prosecuting terrorism.
But it also raises difficult questions.
Why must communities repeatedly experience catastrophic attacks before effective security measures become visible?
What happened to the intelligence networks that should identify organised threats before innocent people are slaughtered?
And what has the Nigerian state done to ensure that another Owo never occurs?
Justice after a massacre is necessary. Preventing the massacre is the greater obligation of government.
SECTION 33: THE RIGHT TO LIFE IS NOT NEGOTIABLE
The Nigerian Constitution is explicit.
Section 33 guarantees every person's right to life, subject only to narrowly defined lawful exceptions.
Section 38 guarantees freedom of thought, conscience and religion, including the right to change one's religion.
Section 10 prohibits the federal or state government from adopting any religion as a state religion.
These are not decorative provisions.
They are constitutional guarantees binding upon the Nigerian state.
A Christian must be free to become a Muslim.
A Muslim must be free to become a Christian.
A traditional worshipper must be free to practise their faith.
And a Nigerian who chooses no religion must enjoy equal protection.
No cleric, pastor, imam, politician, vigilante or mob has the constitutional authority to punish a person for exercising these freedoms.
Any religious doctrine interpreted as authorising extrajudicial killing must yield to the Constitution and the criminal law.
That principle must apply equally to everybody.
SHARIA AND THE CONSTITUTION: THE CONTRADICTION NIGERIA MUST EXAMINE
Nigeria's constitutional arrangement recognises Sharia Courts of Appeal, particularly in matters of Islamic personal law.
Sections 275 and 277 establish and define aspects of their jurisdiction.
But constitutional recognition of religious courts does not grant anyone permission to murder religious converts, persecute minorities or impose private punishment.
There is an important distinction between the peaceful practice of Islamic law within constitutional limits and violent extremism.
Millions of Nigerian Muslims reject terrorism and live peacefully alongside their Christian neighbours. Many Muslims have themselves been victims of insurgency, banditry and extremist violence.
Nevertheless, Nigeria must confront a difficult legal and political question:
Can any religiously based legal arrangement be permitted to operate in a manner that compromises the equal constitutional rights of other citizens?
My position is that the supremacy of the Constitution must never be in doubt.
Any state law, religious rule or enforcement practice that violates fundamental constitutional protections must be subjected to judicial scrutiny.
Nigeria cannot sustain a system in which constitutional citizenship means one thing in one part of the country and something fundamentally different elsewhere.
THE PRESIDENT CANNOT REMAIN A SPECTATOR
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu took an oath to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution.
That oath carries obligations extending beyond economic policy, political appointments and electioneering.
The primary duty of government is the protection of life and property.
When communities are attacked because of their faith, government must respond with intelligence gathering, lawful arrests, impartial prosecution and protection of threatened populations.
It is not enough to issue condolence statements after massacres.
It is not enough to dispatch security delegations after villages have been destroyed.
It is not enough to promise that perpetrators will be brought to justice without subsequently accounting for the investigation.
The Presidency should establish a transparent mechanism for publishing verified information about major religiously motivated attacks, including arrests, prosecutions, convictions and outstanding suspects.
Where a cleric is credibly accused of inciting murder, investigators must preserve the evidence, identify the speaker, establish the context and determine whether criminal offences have been committed.
Religious titles must never confer immunity from criminal investigation.
THE POLITICAL ELITE AND THE TRAGEDY OF SELECTIVE COMPASSION
Another disturbing dimension of Nigeria's security crisis is the distance between those who govern and those who suffer.
For the wealthy and politically connected, insecurity can sometimes be reduced through private guards, fortified residences, protected transportation and the ability to relocate.
But what protection does the ordinary farmer possess?
What protection does a widow in a remote village possess?
What happens to a family whose children cannot attend school because the roads are unsafe?
The consequences of insecurity are not distributed equally.
This inequality creates a dangerous impression that the lives of ordinary Nigerians are less important than the comfort of those in power.
No responsible society should tolerate such a perception.
A president's life is valuable.
A governor's life is valuable.
But the life of an unknown rural woman is equally valuable before the Constitution.
A nation that cannot protect its poorest citizens has failed a fundamental test of government.
IS NIGERIA'S PROBLEM MERELY BAD LEADERSHIP, OR SOMETHING DEEPER?
For decades, Nigerians have been told that the country's problems can be resolved simply by electing better leaders.
There is considerable truth in the importance of competent leadership.
But leadership alone cannot settle every disagreement about identity, religion, federalism and political belonging.
Nigeria contains communities with different historical experiences, legal traditions, political aspirations and understandings of national identity.
Diversity itself is not the problem.
The problem arises when institutions fail to guarantee equality, resolve disputes peacefully and command the confidence of the people.
This brings us to the question that successive administrations have often avoided.
What happens when substantial populations no longer believe that the existing constitutional arrangement adequately protects their lives, freedoms and collective aspirations?
The answer cannot be endless intimidation.
Nor can it be the assumption that every demand for restructuring or self-determination amounts to hostility against fellow citizens.
A democratic society must permit peaceful constitutional debate about its own future.
THE 1914 AMALGAMATION AND THE UNFINISHED NATIONAL QUESTION
The amalgamation of Northern and Southern Nigeria in 1914 was a British colonial administrative decision.
It was not the product of a modern democratic referendum among all the communities subsequently incorporated into Nigeria.
That historical reality remains relevant to contemporary arguments about the legitimacy and design of the federation.
However, history alone does not determine today's legal arrangements. Nigeria has since undergone independence, constitutional development, military rule and civilian government.
The question today is whether the existing federation commands sufficient democratic consent and delivers adequate protection for its citizens.
For those who advocate restructuring, the answer may be a genuinely decentralised federation.
For advocates of regional autonomy, the answer may be stronger constitutional powers for distinct regions.
For those advocating peaceful self-determination, the question may extend to negotiated separation through an agreed constitutional and democratic process.
These positions deserve serious examination rather than automatic criminalisation.
But whatever political arrangement is eventually pursued, it must protect minorities, preserve freedom of religion, reject forced displacement and prohibit violence against civilians.
No community should be compelled to abandon its ancestral homeland because of its religion.
THE WORLD IS CONFRONTING EXTREMISM — NIGERIA MUST DO THE SAME
Across different countries, governments have debated how to respond to extremist movements that seek to undermine constitutional democracy.
Some have introduced restrictions on organisations accused of supporting terrorism or inciting violence.
France's National Assembly, for example, adopted a nonbinding resolution in January 2026 calling for the Muslim Brotherhood to be placed on the European Union's terrorism list. That is not equivalent to an EU-wide designation or a general prohibition of Sharia.
Nigeria must avoid both extremes: ignoring genuine extremist threats and treating an entire religious community as collectively responsible for terrorism.
Security policy must target criminal conduct, credible threats, financing networks, recruitment structures and those who organise or direct violence.
It must not criminalise peaceful religious identity.
The Nigerian state should be capable of distinguishing between a peaceful imam and a terrorist recruiter, just as it should distinguish between a peaceful Christian preacher and a person inciting attacks against Muslims.
Justice must be impartial or it will not be trusted.
WHAT PRESIDENT TINUBU AND THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY MUST NOW DO
I call for seven urgent national measures:
1. Investigate the alleged murder of the religious convert. Establish the authenticity of the circulating footage, identify the victim and location, and pursue credible suspects through lawful procedures.
2. Investigate reported incitement by extremist preachers. Preserve recordings, examine the statements in context and prosecute provable offences without regard to religious status.
3. Publish a national accountability report on religiously motivated violence. Identify unresolved cases, prosecution outcomes, failures in prevention and measures for protecting vulnerable communities.
4. Review religiously based legislation and enforcement practices. Ensure that no state or institution operates contrary to constitutionally guaranteed fundamental rights.
5. Strengthen protection for vulnerable communities. Prioritise early-warning systems, local intelligence, emergency response and protection for threatened places of worship.
6. Convene a credible national constitutional dialogue. Permit serious discussion of federal restructuring, regional autonomy and lawful pathways for peaceful self-determination.
7. Establish independent oversight of security failures. Where credible warnings were ignored or public officials facilitated criminal violence, ensure transparent investigation and appropriate accountability.
These are not demands against Christianity or Islam.
They are demands for constitutional government.
WE MUST NOT BEQUEATH A COUNTRY OF FEAR TO OUR CHILDREN
As a former member of the Nigerian House of Representatives, I believe public office imposes a responsibility to speak when the foundations of constitutional government are threatened.
The Nigeria we leave behind will be judged not merely by roads constructed, elections conducted or revenue collected.
It will be judged by whether its citizens could live without fear.
Whether children could attend school.
Whether farmers could cultivate their land.
Whether worshippers could enter their churches and mosques without fearing assassination.
Whether citizens could change their religion without inviting violence.
And whether communities could debate their political future without being treated as enemies of the state.
The greatest tragedy would be to pass these unresolved conflicts to another generation while pretending that slogans about national unity constitute a solution.
Unity is valuable.
But unity must be accompanied by justice, consent, equal citizenship and security.
A federation cannot become genuinely united merely by insisting that it must remain united.
It must demonstrate, through its institutions and conduct, that every constituent community has a respected place within it.
MY FINAL MESSAGE TO PRESIDENT TINUBU
Mr President, Nigeria needs more than another declaration condemning terrorism.
It needs demonstrable protection of human life.
It needs a security system that identifies threats before atrocities occur.
It needs a justice system that does not discriminate between victims according to their religion or ethnic origin.
It needs constitutional arrangements capable of commanding the confidence of its diverse peoples.
And it needs the political courage to discuss its future without fear.
Those who believe in a united Nigeria must explain how that unity will guarantee justice and security.
Those who advocate restructuring must present workable constitutional proposals.
Those who advocate peaceful self-determination must be permitted to make their case democratically, while respecting the rights of all affected communities.
What Nigeria cannot afford is the continued substitution of coercion for consent and political rhetoric for constitutional protection.
The right to life must come before the politics of national unity.
The freedom of religion must come before the demands of religious extremism.
And the protection of citizens must come before the preservation of political privilege.
History will not ask how many speeches our leaders delivered after innocent Nigerians were murdered.
It will ask what they did to prevent the next massacre.
MR PRESIDENT, PROTECT THE PEOPLE. DEFEND THE CONSTITUTION. CONFRONT EXTREMISM. AND GIVE NIGERIANS A CREDIBLE, PEACEFUL PATH TO DECIDE THEIR COLLECTIVE FUTURE.
Nigeria must choose constitutional justice over impunity.
The future of our children demands nothing less.
Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano is a medical doctor, former Member of the House of Representatives during Nigeria's Third Republic, and a participant in the country's pro-democracy struggle.
Editorial verification note: The Owo massacre and June 2026 court judgment are supported by published reporting. The separate allegations involving a murdered religious convert, a cleric's recorded threats and an injured minor require independent verification before being reported as established incidents.