8 min read

₦15.8 TRILLION IN SUBSIDY SAVINGS: WHERE IS THE RELIEF FOR SUFFERING NIGERIANS

THREE YEARS AFTER TINUBU REMOVED FUEL SUBSIDY, THE TREASURY REPORTS BILLIONS IN GAINS WHILE MILLIONS OF CITIZENS STILL STRUGGLE WITH POVERTY, TRANSPORT COSTS AND THE PRICE OF FOOD

Professor Moses Ochonu’s criticism of Nigeria’s economic priorities raises a fundamental question: Why should citizens bear the immediate burden of economic reform without adequate social protection?

By Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic

On 29 May 2023, President Bola Ahmed Tinubu stood before Nigerians during his inauguration and announced a policy that would fundamentally alter the economic circumstances of millions of citizens.

“Fuel subsidy is gone.”

Those three words marked the beginning of one of the most consequential economic adjustments in Nigeria's recent history.

The administration presented subsidy removal as a necessary correction to a financially unsustainable system. The government argued that the subsidy consumed enormous public resources, encouraged corruption and smuggling, and prevented the country from investing adequately in development.

But there was another side to the equation.

What would happen to the market woman who transported tomatoes from the village to the city? What would happen to the schoolteacher whose salary could barely cover transportation? What would happen to the small manufacturer operating generators because public electricity remained unreliable?

And what would happen to the millions of Nigerians who had no savings, no unemployment benefits, no reliable public transportation and no meaningful protection against sudden increases in their cost of living?

These questions remain central to the national debate more than three years later.

PROFESSOR MOSES OCHONU'S CHALLENGE TO NIGERIA'S ECONOMIC THINKING

In a widely circulated commentary attributed to Professor Moses Ochonu, the historian challenges those who advocate removing subsidies by invoking free-market economic theories without adequately considering Nigeria's social and institutional circumstances.

He points to the absence or inadequacy of affordable public transportation, unemployment benefits, welfare protections, universal healthcare, subsidised housing and other services that cushion economic hardship in wealthier countries.

His argument exposes a tension in public policy.

In many developed economies, governments allow markets to determine prices while simultaneously supporting vulnerable citizens through public transportation, unemployment insurance, healthcare assistance, food support, housing benefits and targeted subsidies.

Nigeria's circumstances are different.

Although Nigeria has public healthcare, education and social assistance programmes, their coverage, quality and affordability remain uneven. Millions of households must pay directly for services that more comprehensive welfare systems provide or heavily subsidise.

The central question is therefore not whether petrol subsidies are economically efficient.

It is whether the government adequately protected its citizens during the transition to market-based fuel prices.

A country cannot simply import one part of another country's economic philosophy while ignoring the institutions that make that philosophy socially sustainable.

THE ₦15.8 TRILLION QUESTION: FOLLOW THE MONEY

In 2026, the Federal Government provided figures that brought the subsidy debate into sharper focus.

According to its reform scorecard, Nigeria mobilised approximately ₦15.8 trillion in petrol subsidy savings between June 2023 and December 2025.

The government reported that the resources were distributed as follows:

GOVERNMENT-REPORTED SUBSIDY SAVINGS, JUNE 2023–DECEMBER 2025

₦15.8 trillion

Federal Government ₦5.4tn
36 states ₦6.5tn
Local governments ₦3.9tn

These are government-reported fiscal savings, not a separately identifiable cash account. Independent project-by-project verification remains necessary.

These figures raise important accountability questions.

Which roads were constructed with the additional revenue? Which public hospitals were equipped? Which schools were improved? How many affordable buses were purchased and put into service? How many poor households received meaningful and sustained assistance?

The government says the savings helped finance broader expenditure, infrastructure and public programmes. It also acknowledges that the money was pooled with other public revenues rather than held in a distinct subsidy-savings account.

That accounting arrangement makes transparent expenditure tracking particularly important.

The question is not merely whether money entered the Federation Account.

The question is whether Nigerians can trace that money from public revenue to measurable public benefit.

THE IMF'S WARNING: WHERE DID THE EXPECTED SAVINGS GO?

The International Monetary Fund's 2026 assessment identified a significant fiscal transparency problem.

Although subsidy removal was estimated to generate savings worth as much as 2% of GDP, the IMF reported that those savings did not appear to have accrued to the federal budget in 2025 as expected.

The IMF also raised concerns about expenditure reporting, budget implementation and the difficulty of tracking subsidy-related fiscal gains.

This does not establish that ₦15.8 trillion was stolen or disappeared. The government's figures concern broader Federation resources over June 2023–December 2025, whereas the IMF's concern includes whether expected savings were actually reflected in the federal budget in 2025.

Nevertheless, the apparent gap between projected savings, reported revenue gains and identifiable budgetary benefits requires reconciliation.

An independent public audit should establish how much subsidy removal saved, how much was retained by the Federation, what liabilities were deducted, and how the remaining resources were ultimately spent.

THE POVERTY CONTRADICTION: ECONOMIC GROWTH WITHOUT ADEQUATE RELIEF

The World Bank's October 2025 Nigeria Development Update estimated that poverty could reach 61% of the population, approximately 139 million people, during 2025.

The same report acknowledged improvements in economic stabilisation but warned that the gains had not substantially improved household livelihoods.

There has since been measurable progress in some macroeconomic indicators.

In its report released on 8 October 2026, the World Bank recorded real GDP growth of 4.2% in the first half of 2026 and reported that Nigeria's poverty rate had stabilised for the first time since 2019.

Yet inflation remained elevated, and households continued to experience pressure on their purchasing power.

These findings demonstrate why Nigeria's economic situation cannot be reduced to a simple claim that everything has improved or everything has deteriorated.

Growth in national output is important. So are rising revenues, foreign reserves and improved fiscal balances.

But families cannot pay school fees with GDP statistics.

They cannot purchase medication with announcements about foreign reserves.

And they cannot feed their children with projections of future prosperity.

Economic recovery must eventually be reflected in real household incomes, employment opportunities and affordable essential services.

THE SOCIAL SAFETY NET: WHAT DID THE POOR RECEIVE?

One of the most important promises associated with subsidy removal was that vulnerable Nigerians would receive compensatory support.

Yet the IMF's 2026 report stated that approximately 9.2 million households had been enrolled in the cash-transfer system, against a target of 15 million.

It also reported that enrolled households had received, at most, three payments of ₦25,000 each since 2023.

SOCIAL PROTECTION PROGRAMME — IMF 2026 ASSESSMENT

15m

Target households

9.2m

Enrolled households

Approximately 61% of targeted households enrolled; enrollment does not necessarily establish complete payment delivery.

For a household struggling with years of rising transport, food, rent and medical costs, a maximum of ₦75,000 in reported transfers over several years raises serious questions about the adequacy and regularity of the intervention.

A functioning safety net should not depend on occasional payments alone. It should provide predictable assistance, reliable beneficiary identification and transparent reporting.

THE STATES AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS MUST ALSO ANSWER

The subsidy debate must not end at Aso Rock.

According to the Federal Government's reported distribution, state governments received ₦6.5 trillion of the additional subsidy-related resources, while local governments received ₦3.9 trillion between June 2023 and December 2025.

These amounts were distributed across the respective tiers of government, not paid to any single state or council.

The World Bank's report released yesterday, 8 October 2026, provides additional insight.

It found that aggregate state revenues increased by approximately 93% in real terms between 2023 and 2025, while capital spending expanded.

However, education's share of total state expenditure declined from 14.9% in 2021 to 12.1% in 2025. Health expenditure remained around 7%, while social protection's share rose from 1.4% to 4.4%.

These figures reveal both increased fiscal capacity and continuing questions about spending priorities.

Governors and local government chairmen must therefore provide independently verifiable accounts of the additional resources they received.

How many functional primary healthcare centres were delivered? How many classrooms were rehabilitated? How many rural roads were completed? How many vulnerable families received support?

The responsibility for translating increased public revenue into better living conditions belongs to all three tiers of government.

SUBSIDY REMOVAL OR SUBSIDY REFORM: THE ALTERNATIVE ARGUMENT

Supporters of removing the former petrol subsidy have a serious economic argument.

The old subsidy was costly, poorly targeted and vulnerable to corruption. Wealthier households generally consumed more petrol directly and therefore captured a disproportionate share of its benefits.

The World Bank's 2023 analysis estimated that poorer Nigerians directly purchased only a small fraction of subsidised petrol.

But this argument does not eliminate the indirect burden on poor households.

When transport costs increase, food distribution becomes more expensive. When generator fuel becomes costlier, small businesses face higher operating costs. When these costs are passed to consumers, even households without private vehicles can suffer.

A more equitable alternative could combine market-based fuel pricing with targeted transport support, reliable cash transfers, improved public electricity and investment in healthcare and education.

Indeed, on 8 October 2026, Reuters reported that the Nigerian government was proposing a petrol price-cap mechanism of approximately ₦1,350 per litre to manage price volatility. It remained a proposal, not an established nationwide price guarantee.

That development illustrates the continuing debate over how governments can limit fuel-price shocks without returning to an open-ended universal subsidy.

TEN QUESTIONS THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY MUST PUT TO THE GOVERNMENT

The National Assembly has constitutional responsibilities concerning public expenditure, oversight and accountability.

A comprehensive public hearing should demand:

  • A reconciled account of subsidy savings from 29 May 2023 to the latest available reporting period.
  • A breakdown of the additional revenues actually received by the Federal Government, each state and each local government.
  • An explanation of the IMF's concerns about subsidy savings not appearing in the 2025 federal budget.
  • A list of projects and programmes funded from the additional fiscal resources, including contract values, contractors and completion status.
  • Audited information on the implementation of the cash-transfer programme.
  • Evidence of investments in affordable public transportation.
  • An assessment of changes in household purchasing power and real wages.
  • An account of how subsidy removal affected small businesses, agriculture and manufacturing.
  • A reconciliation of additional borrowing, debt-service expenditure and subsidy-related fiscal gains.
  • A published timetable for converting higher public revenues into measurable improvements in healthcare, education, employment and essential infrastructure.

These questions should be directed not only to the Presidency and federal economic managers but also to state governments and local government authorities.

NIGERIANS DESERVE MORE THAN PROMISES OF TOMORROW

The debate over petrol subsidy removal should never be reduced to an argument between those who understand economics and those who supposedly do not.

It is a debate about public finance, social justice, economic efficiency and the responsibilities of government.

Nigeria must confront two realities simultaneously.

The former petrol subsidy system imposed substantial costs and contained serious structural weaknesses.

But removing that system without sufficiently protecting vulnerable households created difficult economic adjustments whose effects have extended far beyond petrol stations.

A government may legitimately pursue fiscal reform. Citizens may equally demand evidence that the reform is improving their lives.

And where economic sacrifice is required, the public is entitled to know how the burden is distributed, who benefits and whether those with the least capacity to endure hardship are being adequately protected.

Professor Moses Ochonu's commentary draws attention to precisely this issue: the danger of adopting economic prescriptions without accounting for the social conditions in which they operate.

The test of reform is not simply the courage to announce it.

It is the capacity to implement it fairly, transparently and effectively.

THE FINAL QUESTION

Three years after the removal of petrol subsidy, the Federal Government reports substantial fiscal savings. International institutions acknowledge improvements in macroeconomic stability. Yet those same institutions continue to warn about poverty, household purchasing power and inadequate social protection.

The National Assembly must scrutinise the figures. The Auditor-General and relevant oversight institutions must help establish a transparent financial trail. Governors must account for the increased resources flowing to their states. Local governments must demonstrate what communities have received.

And the Federal Government must show Nigerians how the sacrifices imposed since May 2023 are translating into tangible benefits.

Because the ultimate measure of an economic policy is not merely how much money government saves. It is whether the lives of the people become more secure, more productive and more dignified.

The question Nigerians should continue to ask is simple:

₦15.8 TRILLION REPORTED IN SUBSIDY SAVINGS — WHERE ARE THE MEASURABLE BENEFITS FOR THE PEOPLE WHO PAID THE PRICE?

Sources: Federal Ministry of Information and National Orientation, August 2026; IMF Nigeria Article IV Consultation, 2026; World Bank Nigeria Development Updates, October 2025 and October 2026; Reuters, October 2026. Government-reported savings are distinguished from independently verified expenditure outcomes throughout this article.

Type at least two letters to search titles, summaries and topics.