NIGERIA CANNOT DEMAND UNITY WHILE TOLERATING ETHNIC HOSTILITY, DISCRIMINATION AND THE DENIAL OF EQUAL CITIZENSHIP
When a people repeatedly feel unwanted in the country they call home, their demand for dignity, justice and the freedom to determine their political future should not be dismissed without addressing the grievances behind it.
By Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano
Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic | June 12 Legislator
THE GREAT CONTRADICTION OF THE NIGERIAN UNION
There is a fundamental contradiction at the heart of Nigeria's unresolved national question.
How can a country expect unquestioning loyalty from a people who believe they are repeatedly treated as outsiders? How can a nation preach unity while ethnic insults, stereotypes, threats and discriminatory conduct continue to undermine the confidence of some of its citizens?
And, perhaps most importantly, how can those who condemn demands for self-determination refuse to confront the conditions that give rise to such demands?
These are not questions that can be answered through intimidation, political slogans or appeals to patriotism alone.
They require justice.
They require honesty.
Above all, they require a serious examination of the relationship between the Nigerian state and the various peoples who constitute it.
The Igbo question is not simply about Biafra. It is about citizenship, historical memory, political representation, economic opportunity, security, dignity and the meaning of belonging to Nigeria.
A country cannot reasonably expect its citizens to feel equally invested in its future unless they believe they have an equal stake in its institutions.
THE WOUNDS OF HISTORY CANNOT BE ERASED BY COMMAND
The Nigerian Civil War of 1967–1970 remains one of the defining tragedies of our national history.
The violence preceding the war, the mass displacement, the suffering of civilians and the enormous loss of human life left wounds that have passed from one generation to another.
The declaration of No Victor, No Vanquished at the end of the war was intended to signal reconciliation.
But reconciliation is not merely a presidential declaration. It is a continuing obligation.
It requires that citizens see fairness in government appointments, access to national opportunities, infrastructure development, political participation and the administration of justice.
For many Igbo people, the question is whether the promises of postwar reconciliation have been sufficiently fulfilled.
That question deserves an answer grounded in evidence and public accountability, not an accusation of disloyalty.
A federation that wishes to remain united must be prepared to listen to the grievances of its constituent peoples.
YOU CANNOT DEMAND LOVE THROUGH INTIMIDATION
Patriotism is not manufactured by force.
National unity is not achieved by ordering citizens to suppress their identities or remain silent about their grievances.
It develops when citizens believe the state protects them equally, regardless of their ethnicity, religion, language or place of origin.
When an Igbo trader, professional, student or political participant experiences ethnic hostility, the injury goes beyond the individual. It raises questions about whether the promise of equal citizenship is being honoured.
When an entire ethnic community is stereotyped because of the actions or political opinions of some of its members, the consequences can be particularly damaging.
No Nigerian should be made to feel that their ethnic identity is a permanent obstacle to full citizenship.
And no Nigerian should be required to surrender their cultural identity as the price of national acceptance.
A nation worthy of loyalty must demonstrate that loyalty to its citizens is reciprocal.
SELF-DETERMINATION IS A POLITICAL QUESTION, NOT AN EXCUSE FOR ETHNIC PERSECUTION
The right to discuss self-determination is recognised within international human rights law.
Article 20 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights recognises the right of peoples to self-determination, while Article 19 affirms their equality and protection against domination. Nigeria incorporated the Charter into domestic law through its Ratification and Enforcement Act.
However, the legal distinction must be understood: self-determination does not automatically establish an unconditional right to unilateral secession. African human rights jurisprudence also recognises forms of internal self-determination, including meaningful political participation, cultural autonomy and protection against discrimination.
This makes dialogue essential.
Those who advocate the continued unity of Nigeria have legitimate arguments about national stability, shared citizenship and the dangers of fragmentation.
Those who advocate peaceful Biafran self-determination raise questions about political consent, historical grievances and the future constitutional relationship between peoples.
Neither position justifies ethnic hatred, collective punishment or violence against civilians.
WHAT DOES THE NIGERIAN CONSTITUTION SAY?
Section 42 of the 1999 Constitution prohibits specified forms of discrimination based on ethnic group, community, place of origin, religion and political opinion.
Section 39 protects freedom of expression, subject to constitutional limitations.
These guarantees must mean something in everyday life.
They should be reflected in access to public employment, protection by security agencies, fair political competition and the treatment of Nigerians who live outside their ancestral states.
The government has a responsibility to investigate credible allegations of discrimination and provide effective remedies where violations are established.
Constitutional equality cannot remain a beautiful promise printed in a document while citizens experience something different in practice.
THE REAL QUESTION BEFORE PRESIDENT TINUBU AND THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu and the National Assembly face an enduring constitutional challenge: how can Nigeria strengthen national belonging while responding credibly to the grievances of its constituent communities?
The answer requires more than ceremonial declarations of national unity.
It requires measurable reforms, transparent federal appointments, equitable infrastructure planning, fair enforcement of the law, protection of minority communities and meaningful constitutional dialogue.
A national conversation on restructuring, federalism and self-determination should not be treated as a threat simply because the questions are uncomfortable.
Political disagreement is not, by itself, disloyalty.
A citizen who questions the structure of the federation is not thereby an enemy of the country.
And a citizen who wishes to preserve Nigeria's unity is not thereby an enemy of the Igbo people.
The test of a functioning democracy is whether these differences can be expressed, debated and resolved through peaceful constitutional processes.
THE DANGER OF MAKING AN ENTIRE PEOPLE FEEL UNWANTED
The consequences of ethnic exclusion extend far beyond politics.
They affect the willingness of citizens to invest, establish businesses, relocate, build friendships and imagine a shared future.
They influence how young people interpret their country's history and whether they regard national institutions as their own.
The language used by political leaders, community figures and public commentators therefore matters.
A reckless ethnic statement may be uttered in seconds, but its effects on trust can last for generations.
Nigeria's diversity is a permanent feature of its society. The question is whether that diversity will be governed through mutual respect or continually strained by suspicion and competition.
There is no justification for portraying all Igbo people as separatists, just as there is no justification for portraying all members of any other Nigerian ethnic group as oppressors.
Collective blame is incompatible with equal citizenship.
THE FINAL QUESTION: WHAT KIND OF NIGERIA ARE WE BUILDING?
Nigeria must confront an uncomfortable reality: political unity and national belonging are not necessarily the same thing.
A country may remain geographically intact while its citizens become increasingly alienated from one another.
It may possess a constitution, a flag and a national anthem while leaving important questions about fairness and identity unresolved.
The response must be a renewed commitment to justice, democratic accountability and peaceful engagement.
If Nigeria is to remain united, its unity must be made credible through the treatment of its citizens.
If demands for self-determination persist, they must be addressed through dialogue, lawful processes and respect for human rights rather than ethnic hostility.
And whatever constitutional future Nigerians ultimately pursue, the rights and safety of all communities must remain non-negotiable.
The measure of a nation's unity is not how loudly its leaders demand allegiance, but how fairly its institutions treat the people from whom that allegiance is expected.
A federation that wants to endure must make every citizen feel that they belong.
That is the challenge before Nigeria.
That is the challenge before its leadership.
And that is the challenge that cannot be answered by intimidation, silence or another empty declaration of unity.
Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic June 12 Legislator Awkuzu, Anambra State, Nigeria
Opinion commentary | 11 October 2026