FROM OPERATION PYTHON DANCE TO TERRORIST ABDUCTIONS, MILITARY INTELLIGENCE FAILURES AND ALLEGATIONS OF STATE COMPLICITY — NIGERIA MUST ANSWER THE QUESTIONS DESTROYING PUBLIC CONFIDENCE IN ITS ARMED FORCES.
A nation cannot brutalise its citizens, dismiss their grievances, demand their loyalty and then wonder why its young people hesitate to wear its military uniform.
By Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano
Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic | June 12 Legislator
THE ARMY CANNOT DEMAND LOYALTY WITHOUT EARNING TRUST
There comes a time in the history of every nation when its greatest danger is no longer merely the enemy carrying weapons against it, but the collapse of confidence between the government and the governed.
Nigeria is dangerously approaching that point.
For many Igbo citizens, the sight of a Nigerian military uniform no longer automatically represents protection, patriotism, national pride or reassurance. For some, it evokes memories of military intimidation, humiliating checkpoints, alleged extrajudicial killings, and the painful experience of being treated as suspects in their own country.
This is a national tragedy.
When young people begin to regard the institution established to defend them as an institution they must fear, something fundamental has gone wrong with the republic.
The Nigerian Army should belong equally to the Igbo, Hausa, Fulani, Yoruba, Ijaw, Tiv, Ibibio, Kanuri and every other nationality within Nigeria.
It must never become, or be perceived to have become, an instrument of ethnic domination, political punishment or religious intimidation.
Yet that is precisely the crisis of perception that Nigeria's political and military leadership must confront.
OPERATION PYTHON DANCE: THE WOUNDS THAT HAVE NOT HEALED
Under the administration of President Muhammadu Buhari, the Nigerian Army conducted Operation Python Dance in the South-East.
The military presented the operation as a response to security threats, including criminality and violent activities.
But among many residents, its legacy became associated with fear, alleged abuses, confrontation with separatist protesters and the militarisation of civilian communities.
The treatment of civilians during military operations became a major source of controversy.
Reports and allegations of degrading treatment, excessive force and unlawful killings demanded credible investigations and accountability.
The central question remains unanswered in the minds of many citizens:
How can a young Igbo man who believes soldiers humiliated his community be expected to develop enthusiasm for joining the same institution?
Patriotism cannot be manufactured through intimidation.
National loyalty cannot be commanded at gunpoint.
Respect for the armed forces must grow from their professionalism, impartiality, discipline and demonstrated commitment to protecting every Nigerian.
The Nigerian Civil War ended in January 1970. Its historical consequences remain important, but it would be a mistake to attribute every contemporary concern about military recruitment in the South-East to that conflict.
Today's young people also judge the military by what they have witnessed during their own lifetimes.
And their questions deserve answers.
WHEN SOLDIERS WITHDRAW AND SCHOOLCHILDREN ARE ABDUCTED, WHO GAVE THE ORDER?
Perhaps even more disturbing than the deterioration of civil-military relations are allegations that security failures have sometimes enabled terrorist attacks.
Nigeria has repeatedly witnessed the abduction of innocent schoolchildren, attacks on communities and the killing of military personnel.
In some incidents, questions have been raised about why security personnel were absent, withdrawn or unable to intervene before attackers struck.
Where soldiers were withdrawn shortly before an attack, Nigerians are entitled to know why.
Was the withdrawal ordered?
Who authorised it?
Was there an intelligence warning?
Was the withdrawal a tactical decision, a failure of coordination or evidence of something more sinister?
These questions must not be dismissed as political propaganda.
Equally, allegations that senior government officials deliberately ordered soldiers to facilitate kidnappings must not be presented as established facts without verifiable evidence.
The consequences of such wrongdoing, if proved, would be enormous.
It would represent not merely a failure of security but a betrayal of the constitutional responsibility to protect human life.
A government that cannot explain a catastrophic security failure cannot reasonably expect the public to stop asking questions.
THE KEBBI SCHOOL ABDUCTION: A CASE THAT DEMANDS ANSWERS
This is not merely a hypothetical concern.
On 17 November 2025, armed attackers invaded Government Girls Comprehensive Secondary School in Maga, Kebbi State, killing the vice-principal and abducting schoolgirls.
Governor Nasir Idris subsequently alleged that soldiers deployed to protect the school had withdrawn at approximately 3 a.m., shortly before the attack.
He demanded to know who authorised their withdrawal.
Defence Headquarters acknowledged the allegation and announced a review of troop movements, while explaining that military deployments are guided by intelligence and operational considerations.
Here is the fundamental issue.
A school received protection because an attack was feared. Soldiers reportedly departed. The attackers arrived. Children were abducted.
That sequence does not, by itself, prove deliberate collaboration with terrorists.
But it absolutely demands a transparent explanation.
What did the investigation discover? Who made the deployment decisions? Were disciplinary measures necessary? What safeguards were introduced to prevent another tragedy?
Nigerians deserve published findings, not permanent uncertainty.
WHEN EVEN GENERALS ARE KILLED, WHO IS SAFE?
The killing of senior military officers in terrorist attacks raises another urgent question about operational security.
In November 2021, Brigadier-General Dzarma Zirkusu and three soldiers were killed during fighting against ISWAP terrorists in Borno State. The Nigerian Army confirmed their deaths and described their sacrifice in defence of the country.
Such losses expose the extraordinary dangers faced by military personnel.
Allegations of leaked intelligence, compromised communications and betrayal from within security structures must be investigated wherever credible evidence exists.
But those allegations must be distinguished from verified facts.
The courage of officers and soldiers who confront terrorists should never be confused with the failures of the political and military institutions responsible for equipping, directing and protecting them.
The Nigerian soldier is not the enemy of the Nigerian people. The real enemies are terrorism, corruption, impunity, discrimination and any abuse of public authority that endangers innocent lives.
GOVERNOR SOLUDO AND THE QUESTION OF IGBO MILITARY RECRUITMENT
If Governor Charles Soludo or any other public official wants more young people from the South-East to join the Nigerian Armed Forces, the conversation must extend beyond recruitment appeals.
The fundamental issue is confidence.
Young people need assurance that they will enter a truly national institution where their ethnicity, religion and state of origin will not determine their opportunities, promotion or treatment.
They must believe that military service is an honourable career and not an invitation to become expendable instruments of political interests.
The government should publish credible, state-by-state recruitment and representation figures, examine any disparities, and ensure transparent selection and promotion procedures.
There are many courageous Igbo officers who have served Nigeria with distinction. Their service must not be erased by legitimate criticism of military conduct.
The solution is not to discourage Igbo youths from serving their country.
It is to make the armed forces worthy of the trust and sacrifice of every Nigerian youth.
THE HUMAN-RIGHTS RECORD CANNOT BE SWEPT UNDER THE CARPET
The evidence of serious grievances is not confined to social-media commentary.
In November 2016, Amnesty International reported that at least 150 peaceful pro-Biafra protesters had been killed by security forces between August 2015 and August 2016.
Its findings were based on video recordings, photographs and eyewitness testimony.
A further Amnesty International report published in 2025 examined a decade of violence and impunity in the South-East, including allegations of abuses during military operations.
These findings demand meaningful investigation, fair judicial proceedings and remedies for victims.
The Nigerian Constitution guarantees the right to life under Section 33 and the dignity of the human person under Section 34.
These rights do not disappear because someone belongs to IPOB, supports Biafran self-determination, criticises the government or lives in a community suspected of harbouring criminals.
Where individuals commit crimes, they should face lawful investigation and prosecution.
Collective punishment is not justice.
Military intimidation is not patriotism.
And the killing of unarmed civilians cannot be excused as national security.
RELIGION MUST NEVER BECOME A WEAPON OF STATE POWER
Another dangerous dimension of Nigeria's security crisis is the growing fear among some communities that religious identity influences the distribution of state protection.
The violence perpetrated by Boko Haram and ISWAP, including attacks on Christians, Muslims and other civilians, has devastated communities and undermined confidence in government.
Allegations that public officials deliberately support such organisations are grave and must be investigated where credible evidence is available. They cannot simply be assumed true.
Nigeria is a constitutionally secular federation in the sense that Section 10 prohibits the federal or state governments from adopting any religion as a state religion.
Every Christian, Muslim and adherent of traditional religion must enjoy equal citizenship.
No citizen should fear that the government will abandon them because of their faith.
And no religion should be collectively blamed for the crimes of terrorists.
NIGERIA'S UNITY MUST BE BASED ON CONSENT, NOT FEAR
Nigeria's greatest unresolved political question may ultimately be whether its constituent peoples genuinely believe they are equal partners in a common national project.
The amalgamation of 1914 brought together peoples with different histories, languages, religions and political traditions.
More than a century later, the argument about how these communities should coexist remains unsettled.
Some Nigerians believe restructuring, genuine federalism, state policing, fiscal autonomy and constitutional reforms can preserve the federation.
Others believe the accumulation of injustice has made peaceful self-determination and negotiated separation preferable.
Both positions deserve democratic discussion.
The experiences of India and Pakistan, Sudan and South Sudan, and the former Yugoslavia demonstrate that political unions can change. They also demonstrate that partition can produce enormous suffering and does not automatically resolve religious or ethnic conflict.
The lesson must therefore be peaceful dialogue, democratic legitimacy, constitutional negotiation and protection of minorities.
No nation can achieve lasting unity by making the demand for unity more important than the dignity of its citizens.
PRESIDENT TINUBU: THE TIME FOR ANSWERS IS NOW
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, as Commander-in-Chief, bears the ultimate political responsibility for ensuring that Nigeria's security institutions operate within the Constitution.
The National Assembly must also exercise its oversight powers independently and fearlessly.
I therefore call for five urgent measures:
1. An independent public inquiry into credible allegations of unlawful killings, torture and degrading treatment during security operations in the South-East.
2. Publication of findings on the Kebbi school abduction, including the circumstances of the reported troop withdrawal and any accountability measures taken.
3. An independent review of intelligence compromises and military ambushes, including allegations that sensitive operational information has reached terrorist organisations.
4. A transparent audit of military recruitment, representation and promotion, ensuring equal opportunity for qualified Nigerians from every state.
5. A national constitutional dialogue on restructuring, federalism, minority protections and peaceful democratic mechanisms for addressing demands for self-determination.
These are not unreasonable demands.
They are the minimum obligations of a government that claims to derive its authority from the people.
MY FINAL MESSAGE: A COUNTRY MUST PROTECT ITS PEOPLE BEFORE DEMANDING THEIR PATRIOTISM
I served in Nigeria's House of Representatives during the Third Republic.
I know that patriotism is not measured by the volume with which political leaders shout about national unity.
It is measured by the justice they deliver, the lives they protect, the rights they respect and the confidence they inspire.
I refuse to accept that Nigerian children should be abducted from their classrooms while the public is left wondering why their protectors were absent.
I refuse to accept that the death of a soldier should be treated as an ordinary statistic.
I refuse to accept that young Igbo people should be expected to overlook serious allegations of abuse simply because political leaders demand unquestioning loyalty.
And I refuse to accept that the discussion of peaceful self-determination should be treated as more dangerous than the injustices that give rise to it.
Nigeria cannot continue to demand the sacrifices of citizenship while neglecting the responsibilities of government.
A military uniform should inspire confidence, not terror.
A national flag should represent equal citizenship, not exclusion.
And a government should be the protector of its people, never the object of their deepest fear.
If Nigeria wants Igbo youths to join its armed forces, let Nigeria first demonstrate that those armed forces belong to them as much as to every other Nigerian.
If Nigeria wants unity, let it deliver justice.
If Nigeria wants patriotism, let it earn trust.
And if Nigeria wants to survive as one country, let it finally confront the grievances that threaten to tear it apart.
Because the most dangerous moment in the life of a nation is not when citizens begin to question its unity.
It is when they begin to believe that the institutions established to protect them can no longer be trusted.
NIGERIA MUST CHOOSE: JUSTICE AND EQUAL CITIZENSHIP — OR A CONTINUING CRISIS OF NATIONAL CONFIDENCE.
Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano
Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic (1992–1993)
June 12 Legislator | Founding Member, All Progressives Grand Alliance (APGA)