8 min read

TINUBU'S FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY UNDER FIRE: WHO IS ACCOUNTING FOR NIGERIA'S BILLIONS IN BORROWING?

SPECIAL INVESTIGATIVE REPORT | SUNDAY, 18 OCTOBER 2026

Budget Reports Delayed, Debt Burden Mounts, Capital Projects Struggle — Has Nigeria Abandoned the Fiscal Responsibility Act?

As Nigerians struggle with economic hardship, a fundamental constitutional and financial accountability question confronts the Presidency: How can a government continue borrowing, spending and servicing debts when citizens and legislators cannot obtain timely reports showing how public money has been utilised?

By Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okechukwu David Umeano

Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic (1992–1993)

A NATION BORROWING IN THE DARK

Nigeria is confronting a disturbing fiscal accountability crisis that deserves urgent national attention.

Under President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, the Federal Government continues to announce budgets, seek borrowing approvals, service public debts and promise economic recovery.

Yet one fundamental question remains insufficiently answered:

Where are the timely, comprehensive and verifiable budget implementation reports that would enable Nigerians to establish what has actually been earned, borrowed, spent and delivered?

A budget is not evidence of performance. An appropriation is not evidence of payment. A contract award is not evidence of project completion. And a government announcement is not a substitute for audited financial records.

Without timely budget implementation reports, the National Assembly cannot effectively compare promises with results, citizens cannot follow public expenditure, and independent investigators cannot establish whether government borrowing is achieving its stated objectives.

This is not merely an administrative inconvenience.

It is a matter of the rule of law, fiscal discipline, legislative oversight and the economic future of more than 200 million Nigerians.

THE 432-DAY SCANDAL: WHEN ACCOUNTABILITY ARRIVES MORE THAN A YEAR LATE

One particularly disturbing finding exposes the depth of Nigeria's budget transparency problem.

According to an analysis by CFG Advisory, reported by BusinessDay in September 2026, none of the quarterly budget implementation reports examined from the first quarter of 2018 through the third quarter of 2025, where publication dates could be identified, met the statutory 30-day deadline.

The delays ranged from 67 days to an astonishing 432 days.

The first-quarter 2023 report recorded the longest delay, eventually appearing on 5 July 2024, approximately 432 days after its statutory deadline. This particular delay predates Tinubu's presidency, demonstrating that the problem is longstanding rather than exclusive to his administration.

But that history cannot excuse the present government.

President Tinubu assumed office on 29 May 2023. His administration inherited an imperfect fiscal reporting system, but it also inherited the constitutional responsibility to correct it.

Why has the problem continued?

Why should Nigerians be reading reports about expenditure that occurred many months earlier?

How can the National Assembly exercise effective oversight when financial disclosures arrive long after the relevant spending decisions have been made?

And what happens to public accountability when the government responsible for spending public funds also controls the timing of information about that spending?

THE LAW IS CLEAR: QUARTERLY REPORTS ARE NOT OPTIONAL

The Fiscal Responsibility Act 2007 was enacted to promote prudent management of public resources, fiscal stability, transparency and accountability.

Section 30 requires the Minister of Finance, through the Budget Office of the Federation, to monitor budget implementation and report quarterly to the relevant oversight institutions.

The reports must be published no later than 30 days after the end of each quarter.

Section 50 also requires quarterly budget execution summaries and a consolidated annual implementation report.

These are statutory obligations, not ceremonial recommendations.

Yet Nigeria has developed a disturbing administrative culture in which deadlines established by legislation appear increasingly negotiable.

In May 2026, BusinessDay reported that three consecutive quarterly budget implementation reports were outstanding.

The Budget Office subsequently explained that legislative changes, overlapping appropriation periods and reconciliation exercises had complicated the reporting timetable.

Its Director-General, Tanimu Yakubu, argued that fiscal years may be extended through lawful legislative processes and that the outstanding reports were being finalised.

That explanation deserves consideration.

But it raises an even more fundamental legal question:

Does extending the implementation period of a budget automatically suspend the statutory obligation to publish quarterly financial performance reports?

The government must identify the precise legal authority for any departure from the reporting deadlines.

Administrative complexity cannot, by itself, repeal an Act of the National Assembly.

THE WORLD BANK CANNOT BECOME NIGERIA'S BUDGET OFFICE

Nigeria receives periodic assessments from the World Bank, International Monetary Fund and other international financial institutions.

These institutions analyse revenue performance, debt sustainability, inflation, economic growth and public expenditure.

Their assessments can be valuable.

But what has become of our domestic accountability institutions?

Why should Nigerians wait for international institutions to assess the performance of a government whose financial records should already be available to its own citizens?

Nigeria has a Federal Ministry of Finance.

Nigeria has a Budget Office of the Federation.

Nigeria has an Office of the Accountant-General.

Nigeria has an Auditor-General for the Federation.

Nigeria has a Debt Management Office.

Nigeria has a Fiscal Responsibility Commission.

And Nigeria has a National Assembly constitutionally empowered to investigate public expenditure.

With all these institutions, why should budget transparency remain a recurring national controversy?

The World Bank is not elected by Nigerians. It does not appropriate Nigeria's annual budget. It cannot substitute for the National Assembly's oversight responsibility.

The Federal Government must account to Nigerians first.

BORROWING TO SERVICE BORROWING: IS NIGERIA ENTERING A DEBT TRAP?

Perhaps the most frightening aspect of Nigeria's fiscal predicament is the relationship between new borrowing, debt servicing and capital development.

Section 41 of the Fiscal Responsibility Act establishes the general principle that government borrowing should finance capital expenditure and human development, with appropriate legislative approval and sustainable debt management.

The section also contains a specific provision concerning Federal Government borrowing from the capital market, subject to National Assembly approval.

It would therefore be legally inaccurate to suggest that every transaction refinancing an existing debt is automatically prohibited.

Nevertheless, the fundamental economic danger remains.

When a government increasingly depends on fresh borrowing to manage old obligations, it risks entering a cycle in which financial survival consumes resources that should finance development.

Consider the consequences.

Money that should construct hospitals may be diverted to debt servicing.

Money needed to rehabilitate schools may become unavailable.

Roads, water systems, electricity infrastructure and agricultural investments may suffer.

And future generations may inherit obligations without corresponding productive national assets.

The essential question is not simply whether a loan was approved.

It is whether the borrowing was lawful, affordable, properly utilised and capable of producing measurable public benefit.

A nation cannot borrow its way into prosperity if the proceeds of borrowing cannot be traced to productive investments.

THE CAPITAL BUDGET: WHERE ARE THE PROJECTS?

In October 2026, reports continued to highlight problems associated with overlapping budgets, delayed capital implementation and uncertainty surrounding public expenditure.

The Guardian reported that delayed implementation reports had undermined real-time monitoring, while concerns persisted about overlapping appropriation periods and project delivery.

This situation requires more than explanations from government spokespersons.

Nigerians deserve a project-by-project account of federal capital expenditure.

For every capital project, the government should disclose the approved allocation, the amount released, the amount actually paid to contractors, the contractor's identity, the stage of physical completion and the expected completion date.

Without this information, budget figures may create an illusion of development while communities continue to wait for roads, schools, hospitals and electricity.

A capital allocation printed in an appropriation document does not repair a road.

Only implementation does.

THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY MUST NOT BECOME A RUBBER STAMP

The National Assembly possesses extensive constitutional powers over public finance.

It approves appropriations, examines borrowing proposals, scrutinises government expenditure and investigates the administration of public funds.

These powers carry corresponding responsibilities.

How can legislators approve fresh borrowing without adequately examining the performance of earlier loans?

How can lawmakers evaluate new capital allocations when previous capital releases and physical implementation remain insufficiently documented?

How can the National Assembly claim to protect the public purse if it does not insist on timely financial disclosure?

The Senate and House of Representatives must recognise that fiscal oversight is not a favour granted by the Presidency.

It is a constitutional duty.

Where reports are outstanding, the appropriate committees should summon the responsible officials and demand explanations under oath.

Where statutory breaches are established, appropriate enforcement and remedial measures should follow.

Where loan proceeds cannot be adequately accounted for, independent forensic examination should be undertaken.

No democratic government should be permitted to convert parliamentary approval into a blank cheque.

PRESIDENT TINUBU, NIGERIANS DESERVE ANSWERS

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu is the head of the executive branch of government.

The responsibility for ensuring that the Federal Government complies with applicable fiscal laws ultimately rests with his administration.

The President should therefore direct the Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister of the Economy, the Budget Office, the Accountant-General and the Debt Management Office to publish a reconciled account of federal financial performance since 29 May 2023.

The disclosure must answer seven fundamental questions:

  • How much has the Federal Government borrowed domestically and externally since 29 May 2023?
  • How much of the approved borrowing has actually been disbursed?
  • How much has been used for capital projects, human development, refinancing and other authorised purposes?
  • How much has been spent servicing domestic and external debt?
  • Which projects have benefited from the borrowing, and what is their independently verified completion status?
  • Which quarterly budget implementation reports were published late, and what statutory justification is offered for each delay?
  • What measures will guarantee compliance with the Fiscal Responsibility Act going forward?

These are not opposition questions.

They are questions of national survival.

They concern every Nigerian taxpayer, every business owner, every farmer, every pensioner and every child who will inherit the consequences of today's fiscal decisions.

THE WAY FORWARD: A NATIONAL FISCAL ACCOUNTABILITY INVESTIGATION

Nigeria urgently needs an independent and transparent review of federal fiscal operations.

The National Assembly should require the publication of all outstanding quarterly budget reports, accompanied by a clear timetable for future reporting.

It should reconcile approved borrowing with actual disbursements and verify the destinations of loan proceeds.

It should examine the relationship between recurrent expenditure, debt servicing and capital investment.

It should also demand an independent assessment of the sustainability of Nigeria's debt obligations under realistic revenue, exchange-rate and interest-rate assumptions.

Finally, the Fiscal Responsibility Commission must be empowered and supported to perform its statutory monitoring and enforcement functions effectively.

The object should not be to manufacture allegations or conduct a political witch-hunt.

It should be to establish the facts, identify failures, recover misapplied public resources where legally justified, and prevent future violations.

WHAT IS THE FATE OF NIGERIA?

This is the question that should trouble every patriotic Nigerian.

What is the fate of a country where borrowing continues but the public struggles to identify the benefits?

What is the fate of a country where budget implementation reports arrive months after they are legally due?

What is the fate of a country where legislators debate fresh appropriations without a timely and complete picture of previous expenditure?

What is the fate of a country where debt servicing threatens to crowd out the investments necessary for economic growth?

Nigeria's future cannot be secured by presidential assurances alone.

It cannot be secured by impressive budget speeches.

It cannot be secured by celebrating borrowing approvals as though they were development achievements.

It can only be secured through lawful financial management, productive investment, independent scrutiny and public accountability.

The people of Nigeria have a right to know what is being done with their money.

They have a right to know what is being borrowed in their name.

They have a right to know what their children will be expected to repay.

And they have a right to demand that the government obey the very laws it is constitutionally sworn to uphold.

Mr President, publish the accounts. Show Nigerians the projects. Explain the borrowing. Demonstrate compliance with the law.

For a government that promises renewed hope, fiscal accountability must never become a matter of renewed excuses.

NIGERIA CANNOT CONTINUE TO BORROW TODAY, CONCEAL PERFORMANCE UNTIL TOMORROW, AND EXPECT FUTURE GENERATIONS TO PAY WITHOUT QUESTIONS.

Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okechukwu David Umeano

Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic (1992–1993) Public Affairs Commentator and Advocate for Fiscal Accountability

Evidence and legal references: Fiscal Responsibility Act 2007, Sections 30, 41 and 50; CFG Advisory analysis reported by BusinessDay, September 2026; Budget Office statement, 17 May 2026; The Guardian, October 2026. This article distinguishes documented reporting delays from questions requiring further forensic investigation.

Type at least two letters to search titles, summaries and topics.