8 min read

THE WARNING WITHOUT A GUN

Zamfara’s Anti-Christian Chant Raises Urgent Questions About Religious Incitement, Youth Mobilisation and Nigeria’s National Security

A FRONT-PAGE INVESTIGATIVE OPINION

By Our Investigative Desk

ZAMFARA, NIGERIA — 28 OCTOBER 2026

A CHANT THAT NIGERIA MUST NOT IGNORE

The arrest of 22-year-old Umar Ibrahim Gandi Maradun by the Zamfara State Police Command has brought a disturbing question to the centre of Nigeria’s national conversation: how should a country respond when a young man, wearing the uniform associated with a religious organisation, is filmed chanting for weapons to kill Christians?

The video reportedly contains the words, “Give us rifles to go and kill Christians.” According to police accounts published on 27 and 28 October, the footage was recorded on 23 October 2026 in Maradun Local Government Area of Zamfara State. The suspect was reportedly accompanied by pupils from two Islamic schools and was associated with the Jama’atu Izalatil Bidi’a Wa’ikamatus Sunnah, popularly known as JIBWIS.

Police say the investigation is under way and that the suspect may face charges relating to incitement, disturbance of public peace and criminal intimidation. JIBWIS leaders have condemned the video and disassociated the organisation from the alleged conduct.

These are important developments. But they cannot be the end of the investigation.

A call to obtain firearms for the purpose of killing citizens because of their religion is not an ordinary disagreement. It is a matter of public safety that demands a serious, evidence-led response.

Channels Television, TheCable and Premium Times have reported on the arrest and the police investigation.

THE SUSPECT IS ONE QUESTION. THE CIRCUMSTANCES ARE ANOTHER.

The public must resist two equally dangerous errors.

The first is to dismiss the incident as a joke, youthful exuberance or an insignificant performance for social media. A recorded call for religiously targeted violence deserves careful examination, even if no weapon was displayed and no attack has been established.

The second is to declare an entire religious organisation guilty before investigators have established who organised the activity, what authority the participants held and whether the words reflected any broader instruction.

The correct response is neither complacency nor collective accusation. It is a comprehensive investigation.

Who organised the gathering? Who supervised the youths? Who selected or taught the chant? Was the activity part of an authorised programme? Were children knowingly exposed to language advocating violence? Did anyone encourage, facilitate or endorse the threat?

These questions should be answered with witness statements, verified recordings, relevant organisational records and other admissible evidence—not speculation.

WHAT DID THE CHILDREN HEAR, LEARN AND REPEAT?

Perhaps the most troubling dimension of the reported footage is the presence of pupils from two Islamic schools.

Children do not have the same capacity as adults to assess political and religious messages. When young people are exposed to slogans advocating the killing of members of another faith, authorities must establish how the material reached them and whether it formed part of a wider activity.

The investigation should identify the responsible organisers and supervisors, interview relevant witnesses, examine the circumstances in which the video was made and determine whether any school or youth programme was involved.

Amnesty International Nigeria has also called for an investigation into the video, including the organisers of the activity and the possible exposure of children to religious hatred and violence.

The welfare of the children must remain central. They should not be publicly branded as extremists simply because they appear in the footage. Investigators must determine what each child actually did, understood and was instructed to do.

If adults used a religious or educational setting to encourage violence, accountability must extend to those adults where the evidence and law justify it.

JIBWIS MUST ANSWER QUESTIONS ABOUT SUPERVISION AND RESPONSIBILITY

JIBWIS has reportedly condemned the video and handed the suspect over to the police. Its national chairman, Sheikh Abdullahi Bala-Lau, has described the alleged incitement as contrary to the organisation’s teachings and objectives.

That response should be examined fairly. Handing a suspect to law enforcement is relevant evidence of cooperation, although it does not by itself settle every question about the circumstances of the recording.

The organisation should be asked to clarify the status of the uniform seen in the footage, the responsibilities of the group involved, the rules governing youth activities and the measures it takes to prevent religious intolerance.

It should also state clearly whether its authorised teaching materials, youth programmes and public instructions prohibit threats against Christians and other religious communities.

If the investigation establishes that the suspect acted alone and contrary to the organisation’s rules, the evidence should say so. If it establishes that others instructed, encouraged or facilitated the conduct, those individuals should also be investigated.

Institutional responsibility must be established through evidence, not inferred solely from membership or clothing.

RELIGIOUS RHETORIC AND THE DANGER OF DEHUMANISATION

The controversy also raises a broader question about language used by religious leaders.

Words such as “infidel” have different meanings and contexts in theological discussion. Their use alone does not establish an intention to commit violence. But when religious language is combined with an explicit call to shoot or kill people because they are Christians, the distinction between theological disagreement and advocacy of violence becomes critically important.

Public figures who command large followings have a responsibility to make that distinction unmistakable.

Any reported statement by a senior cleric urging followers to “show” Christians their “limit” should be authenticated in its original context. Investigators and journalists should establish who made the statement, when it was made, the exact words used and whether the speaker advocated discrimination, intimidation or violence.

If a religious leader has called for attacks on Christians, that conduct deserves scrutiny and, where the legal threshold is met, appropriate action.

If the statement has been misquoted or taken out of context, that too must be established.

No cleric, political leader or community organiser should be above the law. Nor should any person be condemned on the basis of an unverified quotation.

THE FOREIGN-FUNDING QUESTION REQUIRES DOCUMENTS, NOT ASSUMPTIONS

Questions have also been raised about the historical influence of Saudi-backed Salafi and Wahhabi missionary activity on religious organisations in Nigeria, including the circulation of particular theological texts.

This is a legitimate subject for historical and financial research. However, a claimed ideological connection does not by itself prove that a Nigerian organisation is funded by a foreign government, receives instructions from abroad or supports violence.

Those are separate propositions requiring separate evidence.

A proper investigation would examine available financial records, documented grants, institutional partnerships, published curricula and the provenance of materials used in relevant programmes.

If foreign funding exists, investigators should establish its source, recipients, purpose and conditions. If particular books or sermons are alleged to encourage hostility, their actual contents should be examined rather than described by association alone.

The standard must be the same for every religious institution, whether Islamic, Christian or otherwise.

Foreign influence should be investigated where evidence warrants it. It should not be presumed from theology or religious identity.

UNIFORMED YOUTH GROUPS: WHAT IS THEIR MANDATE?

The video has also raised questions about the organisation of religious youth groups and volunteer units.

Uniforms, coordinated marches and group discipline do not automatically make a religious association a paramilitary organisation. Nor does the presence of a volunteer security or first-aid unit establish that its members possess weapons.

Nevertheless, where a group appears in a recording containing an explicit appeal for firearms to attack a religious community, its activities warrant proportionate scrutiny.

Security agencies should establish the group’s official purpose, training arrangements, leadership structure and authority to provide security at religious events. They should determine whether any firearms were available, whether anyone attempted to obtain them and whether there is evidence of plans for violence.

These are questions to investigate—not conclusions to announce in advance.

Nigeria cannot afford to overlook credible threats simply because they emerge from an institution with a religious identity. Equally, it cannot afford to treat peaceful worshippers or legitimate community volunteers as security threats without evidence.

The governing principle must be conduct, not creed.

WHAT MUST THE POLICE INVESTIGATION ESTABLISH?

The Zamfara State Police Command should provide a clear account of the investigation when doing so will not compromise evidence or public safety.

At a minimum, investigators should:

Authenticate the original video, establish when and where it was recorded, and preserve relevant digital evidence.

Identify the people who organised, participated in or supervised the activity, distinguishing individual conduct from collective responsibility.

Interview relevant witnesses and establish the precise words used, the circumstances of the chant and the intended meaning.

Investigate whether the chant was connected to any actual attempt to acquire firearms, a plan to attack Christians or communications encouraging such conduct.

Examine the involvement of the two schools and protect the privacy and welfare of children appearing in the footage.

Establish the responsibilities of relevant JIBWIS officials and determine whether anyone in a position of authority directed, encouraged, tolerated or opposed the conduct.

Apply the law impartially and ensure that any prosecution is based on evidence and the rights of the accused are respected.

The police have indicated that the case may involve offences under the applicable Zamfara State Penal Code. The precise charges and their legal basis should be confirmed through official court filings and subsequent proceedings.

An arrest is not a conviction. But neither should an arrest be used as a substitute for investigating the wider circumstances.

THE GOVERNMENT MUST PROTECT EVERY NIGERIAN

Nigeria's constitutional order protects freedom of thought, conscience and religion. Those protections include the right to practise a faith and the right not to be threatened because of it.

The government has a duty to protect Christians in Zamfara and elsewhere, just as it must protect Muslims and citizens of every other belief from religiously motivated violence.

That duty requires more than statements of reassurance. It requires credible intelligence, impartial policing, prosecution where the evidence supports it, and safeguards against retaliation and collective punishment.

Christian communities should not be expected to wait for an actual attack before a credible threat is taken seriously. Muslim communities, meanwhile, should not be treated as collectively responsible for the alleged actions of one member.

Religious leaders of every tradition should publicly reject calls to kill, threaten or intimidate people because of their faith.

THE QUESTIONS THAT MUST NOT DISAPPEAR WHEN THE VIDEO FADES

The public should demand answers to five fundamental questions.

Who initiated the chant, and was anyone else directing it?

Were the children merely present, or were they being taught to repeat messages advocating violence?

Did the activity violate the rules of an organisation or institution, and what do its records reveal about supervision?

Is there evidence of a wider plan to acquire weapons or attack Christians, or does the evidence establish only the conduct captured in the video?

Finally, what preventive measures will the authorities and relevant religious institutions implement to ensure that such threats are not repeated?

The answers should come from a transparent investigation, not from rumours, communal anger or assumptions about an entire faith.

EDITORIAL CONCLUSION: DO NOT WAIT FOR A THREAT TO BECOME AN ATTACK

The reported Zamfara video is a warning that must be examined with urgency and precision.

It would be reckless to dismiss an explicit chant calling for firearms to kill Christians. It would be equally reckless to transform the conduct of one suspect into proof that every member of his religious organisation, or every Muslim, shares his alleged views.

The task before the authorities is to determine exactly what happened, identify everyone who bears responsibility and prevent any credible threat from becoming an act of violence.

JIBWIS should cooperate fully, explain the status of the group seen in the video and demonstrate through verifiable actions how its activities guard against incitement. Religious leaders should make clear that theological disagreement does not justify violence. The police should investigate without fear or favour.

The ultimate test is not which religion has the loudest defenders. It is whether every Nigerian can worship, travel, study and live without fear of being targeted for their faith.

A chant is not a gun. But a credible call to obtain guns for religious killing must never be treated as harmless noise. Nigeria must investigate, establish the facts and act before words become violence.

Reporting note: This article distinguishes reported facts from allegations and investigative questions. Claims about foreign financing, senior-leader incitement, weapons availability and institutional direction require independent corroboration before they can be presented as established findings.

Type at least two letters to search titles, summaries and topics.