> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://uhlblog.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# THE NIGERIAN QUESTION HE WANTED NIGERIANS MELTED INTO POTHOLES. BUT WHO GAVE BRITAIN THE RIGHT TO FORCE DIFFERENT PEOPLES INTO ONE COUNTRY?
- URL: https://uhlblog.com/the-nigerian-question-he-wanted-nigerians-melted-into-potholes-but-who-gave-britain-the-right-to-force-different-peoples-into-one-country/
- Published: 2026-11-13T17:39:25.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-13T17:39:25.000Z
- Author: Dr. The Rt. Hon. Okechukwu Umeano

Worked for 22s

### 

INVESTIGATIVE COMMENTARY | NATIONAL IDENTITY | COLONIAL HISTORY | SELF-DETERMINATION

A British councillor has been convicted for making a grotesque racist statement about Nigerians. He deserves condemnation. But his statement raises a much bigger historical question: Why does Britain, whose colonial government constructed Nigeria without the consent of its constituent peoples, remain largely absent from the conversation about the political crisis that has followed?

There is a fundamental difference between wanting a people destroyed and wanting a political arrangement reconsidered.

Nigerians must never be melted, eliminated, humiliated or treated as inferior human beings. But neither should they be compelled to accept indefinitely a political arrangement simply because a colonial administration created it more than a century ago.

The right to live together should be founded on consent, justice, equality and mutual benefit, not historical coercion.

That is the Nigerian question.

### 1\. THE BRITISH CREATED THE FRAMEWORK. NIGERIANS HAVE BEEN LEFT TO MANAGE ITS CONSEQUENCES.

The name Nigeria itself has a colonial history.

The name was proposed by Flora Shaw, a British journalist who later married Frederick Lugard. Her suggestion appeared in The Times on 8 January 1897\. It was subsequently adopted for the British-administered territories.

On 1 January 1914, Lord Frederick Lugard formally amalgamated the Northern and Southern Protectorates under one colonial administration.

What was the justification?

Administrative convenience, railway coordination and economic considerations within the British Empire.

Lugard's own amalgamation speech referred to the need for a unified railway policy. Historical research also documents the British government's financial and administrative calculations, including the economic advantages of combining the territories.

The critical question is this: where, in that decision, was the consent of the ordinary inhabitants of the territories being joined?

There was no nationwide referendum asking the different peoples whether they wished to become one political country.

There was no popular constitutional convention in which all constituent nationalities freely negotiated the terms of their union.

The decision was fundamentally a colonial administrative arrangement. elibrarynigeria.com.ng +2

This does not mean that Nigerians have never subsequently participated in constitutional negotiations or that the country has no legitimate institutions today. They have, and it does.

But independence in 1960 did not erase the historical question of how the original union was created.

Britain transferred sovereignty to a country whose political architecture it had designed. The responsibility for governing that country subsequently passed to Nigerian leaders.

And Nigerian leaders must answer for what they have done with that inheritance.

### 2\. THE HUMAN COST: 1966, THE POGROMS AND THE BIAFRAN WAR

Nigeria's national crisis did not begin with the Biafran declaration of independence in 1967.

The January 1966 coup, the July counter-coup, the killings of political and military leaders, and the subsequent attacks on Ndị́ Ịgbo in parts of Northern Nigeria exposed the fragility of the new federation.

Thousands of Igbo people were killed in the 1966 pogroms. Estimates vary considerably, with scholarly literature discussing figures ranging from approximately 3,000 to 30,000\. Large numbers of survivors fled to the Eastern Region. Taylor & Francis Online +1

Then came the Biafran War, from 1967 to 1970.

The war brought extraordinary suffering, mass displacement, starvation and civilian deaths. Estimates of the total civilian death toll remain contested, but the humanitarian catastrophe was enormous.

We must be historically honest.

The British colonial administration bears responsibility for the structures and policies it established. But the Nigerian military leadership, political elites and successive governments also bear responsibility for their decisions before, during and after the war.

It would be dishonest to blame every Nigerian failure on Britain.

It would equally be dishonest to pretend that colonial history has no bearing on the country's present difficulties.

A country cannot build a sustainable national identity by suppressing the historical grievances of its constituent peoples.

### 3\. THE QUESTION BRITAIN AND NIGERIA MUST ANSWER: CAN A UNION SURVIVE WITHOUT CONSENT?

This is where the argument becomes particularly important.

There are Nigerians who believe that the country should remain united but undergo fundamental restructuring.

There are others who advocate a genuinely federal system in which constituent regions enjoy substantial autonomy.

There are also people, particularly among some pro-Biafra movements, who believe that the political arrangement should be dissolved and that the right to independence should be exercised.

These positions are not identical.

But they all raise a question that cannot be answered simply by declaring that Nigeria's unity is non-negotiable.

Who owns the Nigerian state?

The Nigerian Constitution itself provides an important starting point.

Section 14(2)(a) states that sovereignty belongs to the people of Nigeria, from whom government derives its powers and authority.

This means that the people are the ultimate source of political legitimacy.

Section 2(1), however, describes Nigeria as one indivisible and indissoluble sovereign state.

These provisions create an important constitutional tension for anyone advocating a referendum on the country's continued existence.

The existing Constitution does not provide a straightforward unilateral secession procedure. Constitute +1

Yet the fact that the Constitution protects the territorial integrity of Nigeria does not make the question of political consent illegitimate.

### 4\. THE AFRICAN CHARTER: SELF-DETERMINATION IS A RIGHT, NOT A CRIME

There is a legal instrument Nigeria has ratified that deserves serious attention.

It is the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights, domesticated in Nigeria through the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights (Ratification and Enforcement) Act of 1983.

Article 19 provides that all peoples are equal and that nothing justifies the domination of one people by another.

Article 20(1) states:

> All peoples shall have the unquestionable and inalienable right to self-determination. They shall freely determine their political status.

This is not a slogan invented by separatist activists.

It is a provision of an international human rights instrument to which Nigeria is a party. achpr.au.int +1

However, there is an important legal qualification.

The African Commission considered the issue in Katangese Peoples' Congress v Zaire (Communication 75/92).

The Commission recognised that self-determination could take several forms, including:

- Independence.
- Self-government.
- Local government.
- Federalism.
- Confederalism.
- Unitarism.

But it did not grant Katanga independence. It emphasised territorial integrity and found that the evidence presented did not establish the circumstances necessary to justify secession.

The lesson is significant: self-determination is a recognised right, but it does not automatically confer an unconditional right to unilateral secession. ULII

This distinction is essential to a credible Nigerian debate.

A referendum, freely negotiated constitutional restructuring and an agreed political settlement are legitimate subjects for public discussion.

People advocating peaceful political change should not automatically be equated with those advocating violence.

And a government confident in its legitimacy should be prepared to defend the union through justice, dialogue and democratic consent.

### 5\. THE DOUBLE STANDARD: WHY IS IT WRONG TO DEHUMANISE NIGERIANS BUT CONTROVERSIAL TO ASK THEM WHAT COUNTRY THEY WANT?

On 9 November 2026, Sunderland councillor Glenn Gibbins was convicted after a trial over his Facebook statement suggesting that Nigerians should be melted down and used to fill potholes.

His defence was that it was a joke.

The court rejected that defence. He received a 12-month community order, including 150 hours of unpaid work. He was not imprisoned, and his lawyers indicated that they intended to appeal.

The conviction is significant because the court recognised the dehumanising nature of the statement. ITV News +1

We must applaud the defence of human dignity.

But there is another conversation Nigeria must have.

Why is it so difficult for Nigerians to have an open, peaceful and intellectually honest conversation about the future of their country?

Why should a person who advocates restructuring be branded an enemy of the state?

Why should someone who advocates a referendum automatically be regarded as a threat to national security?

There is a difference between advocating the destruction of human beings and advocating a change in the political structure under which they live.

One is an assault on humanity.

The other is a political proposition that deserves democratic consideration.

We must also be fair: Nigeria's security agencies have legitimate responsibilities to investigate violence, terrorism and genuine threats to public safety. Peaceful advocacy and violent conduct must not be confused.

A government should never be so afraid of a political question that it criminalises the peaceful asking of that question.

### 6\. WHAT SHOULD NIGERIA DO NOW?

The Nigerian political class must stop treating national unity as a slogan that requires no explanation.

Unity is not achieved by constitutional declarations alone.

It requires justice, fairness, security, economic opportunity, political inclusion and confidence that no group is permanently disadvantaged.

I propose five fundamental steps.

First: A genuine national constitutional dialogue.

Nigeria needs a properly constituted national dialogue involving all 36 states, the Federal Capital Territory, ethnic nationalities, traditional institutions, civil society, young people and other stakeholders.

It must address the fundamental structure of the federation.

Second: Genuine restructuring.

The federal government must examine the concentration of political and economic powers at the centre, the viability of the present federal arrangement, resource control, fiscal federalism, state policing and regional autonomy.

Third: A credible national conversation about self-determination.

The country must stop pretending that the demand for self-determination does not exist.

The government should consider a peaceful, constitutionally negotiated mechanism through which Nigerians can express their preferences about the future structure of the federation.

Fourth: Accountability for historical injustices.

The 1966 pogroms, the Biafran War, the humanitarian catastrophe and subsequent grievances deserve serious historical examination.

No nation can permanently bury historical wounds by refusing to discuss them.

Fifth: A new social contract.

If Nigeria is to remain one country, its citizens must have compelling reasons to believe that they are better off together.

That belief cannot be manufactured through military force, political intimidation or patriotic slogans.

It must be earned.

### 7\. BRITAIN MUST ALSO CONFRONT ITS COLONIAL LEGACY

Britain cannot change the events of 1914.

But it can acknowledge the historical circumstances under which Nigeria was constructed.

The British government should recognise that colonial boundaries and administrative decisions had consequences for the peoples brought together under British rule.

This is not a demand that Britain should dictate Nigeria's future.

Quite the opposite.

Nigeria's future must be determined by Nigerians.

But Britain should not be permitted to celebrate the colonial construction of Nigeria as an uncomplicated administrative achievement while ignoring the historical consequences of that construction.

The British Empire has left behind difficult political legacies in several parts of the world.

Nigeria should not be exempt from that historical examination.

### 8\. THE FINAL QUESTION: WHO IS AFRAID OF THE PEOPLE?

Glenn Gibbins was wrong.

His words were racist, degrading and unacceptable.

Nigerians are human beings. They are not road construction materials. They are not a nuisance to be eliminated. They have families, children, ambitions, cultures and histories.

But let us also make something clear.

Nigeria is not a sacred political arrangement beyond discussion.

The 1914 amalgamation was a British colonial decision. Independence in 1960 transferred political responsibility to Nigerians. The subsequent history of military rule, civil war, constitutional disputes, inequality and insecurity has made the question of national cohesion increasingly important.

Those who want Nigeria to remain united must explain why unity serves its peoples.

Those who want restructuring must explain the constitutional and institutional arrangements they propose.

Those who want independence must make their case through peaceful political advocacy and lawful processes.

Nobody should be killed, imprisoned arbitrarily or dehumanised merely for asking what political future they desire.

The African Charter recognises the right of peoples to self-determination. The Nigerian Constitution recognises that sovereignty belongs to the people. These principles deserve to be taken seriously.

And to Britain, our message is simple:

You gave this country its colonial name. Your administration amalgamated its territories. But you did not give Nigerians the right to be treated as inferior human beings, and you did not acquire ownership of their future.

We reject the melting of Nigerians. We reject the dehumanisation of any nationality. But we also reject the idea that national unity must be maintained at all costs, even where justice, equality and consent are absent.

We are not potholes.

We are peoples.

We deserve dignity.

We deserve justice.

And we deserve the right to determine our political future.

THE QUESTION IS NOT WHETHER NIGERIA MUST END. THE QUESTION IS WHETHER NIGERIA CAN BECOME A COUNTRY THAT ALL ITS PEOPLES FREELY CHOOSE TO BELONG TO.

Sources and historical references

- [ITV News – Glenn Gibbins conviction, 9 November 2026](https://www.itv.com/news/tyne-tees/2026-11-09/suspended-reform-councillor-found-guilty-over-offensive-post-about-nigerians?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com).
- [British Colonial Policies and the Challenge of National Unity in Nigeria, 1914–2014](https://journals.co.za/doi/10.18820/24150509/SJCH47.v1.3?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com).
- [Richard Bourne – Nigeria: A New History of a Turbulent Century](https://www.elibrarynigeria.com.ng/files/books/0.312863001602970778NigeriaANewHistoryofaTurbulentCenturybyRichardBourne%28z-lib.org%29.pdf?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com).
- [African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights – African Commission](https://achpr.au.int/en/charter/african-charter-human-and-peoples-rights?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com).
- [Katangese Peoples' Congress v Zaire – African Commission decision](https://ulii.org/en/akn/aa-au/judgment/achpr/1992/3/eng%401992-01-01?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com).
- [Nigerian Constitution – Senate Committee on Constitution Review](https://sccr.gov.ng/?p=121&utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com).

Editorial note: This article deliberately distinguishes historical facts, constitutional provisions and political arguments. The call for a referendum is presented as a proposal for peaceful democratic consideration, not as an assertion that Nigeria's existing Constitution already guarantees unilateral secession.

The strongest argument is not that Nigeria must necessarily break up. It is that a country should not be held together by fear when it could be held together by justice and consent.