> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://uhlblog.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The comparison is now grounded in published evidence
- URL: https://uhlblog.com/the-comparison-is-now-grounded-in-published-evidence/
- Published: 2026-10-28T18:12:38.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-28T18:12:38.000Z
- Author: Dr. The Rt. Hon. Okechukwu Umeano

### 

The official audit trail confirms that Nigeria has separate reporting systems for solid minerals and petroleum. NEITI publishes annual solid-minerals audits through 2023, including revenue, production and validation data, and oil-and-gas audits covering production, company payments and government receipts. NEITI +1

One important finding already emerges: a May 2026 report on NEITI's mining-sector investigation estimated that about 80% of mining in the North-West was illegal. This is a reported regional estimate, not proof that 80% of all northern mining—or mining in every northern state—is illegal. Kitco News

### 1\. State-by-state comparison: where the evidence leads

Reporting period: primarily 2023, the latest year for which the reviewed NEITI sector audits provide a common, published comparison. The 2026 mining-sector findings are included separately as recent enforcement evidence.

| State / region | Principal resource examined | What the evidence establishes                                                                                  | What remains to be verified                                                            |
| -------------- | --------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Zamfara        | Gold                        | Illegal mining and illicit mineral trading are significant documented problems in the North-West. Kitco News+1 | State-specific production value, royalties actually paid, and revenue lost.            |
| Plateau        | Tin and other minerals      | The solid-minerals sector has an established history of commercial mining and federal licensing.               | Current state-specific production, royalty receipts and enforcement totals.            |
| Nasarawa       | Lithium and other minerals  | Authorities have conducted enforcement operations against alleged illegal mining in the state. AP News         | Licensed versus unlicensed output, export values and state-specific collections.       |
| Bayelsa        | Petroleum                   | The state recorded ₦476.67 billion in oil-and-gas derivation revenue in 2024 in the NGF fiscal database.       | Historical year-by-year receipts and expenditure reaching individual Ijaw communities. |
| Rivers         | Petroleum                   | Rivers is a major oil-producing state within the federal petroleum revenue framework.                          | Annual derivation receipts, deductions, expenditure and community-level benefits.      |
| Delta          | Petroleum                   | NEITI and FAAC reporting provide a basis for tracing petroleum-related revenue and derivation transfers.       | A complete, reconciled annual record of production, receipts and local outcomes.       |

Important: The published evidence does not yet provide comparable state-by-state totals for all six cases. In particular, the illegal-mining estimate for the North-West cannot be applied automatically to Zamfara alone, and national petroleum revenue cannot be attributed entirely to Ijaw territory.

### 2\. What the national accounts reveal

The 2023 NEITI oil-and-gas audit records US$30.852 billion in total sector revenue, down from US$35.772 billion in 2022\. This total includes multiple financial flows and in-kind payments; it is not the amount paid exclusively into the Federation Account. EITI +1

The NEITI solid-minerals audit reports revenue contribution rising from ₦345.41 billion in 2022 to ₦401.6 billion in 2023, an increase of approximately 16%. These are sector-level figures, not the amount earned by northern states alone. neiti.gov.ng

The State House has also explained that solid minerals and petroleum both fall under federal control and that producing states are eligible for the 13% derivation principle on qualifying natural-resource revenue accruing to the Federation Account. It identifies private-sector participation as a key difference between the two industries. The State House, Abuja

That is a significant correction to the idea that solid minerals are legally free for anyone to mine. The stronger concern is whether widespread informal extraction and weak enforcement allow some operators to bypass the legal framework.

### 3\. The accountability test

The next ledger should be populated from three official sources:

![neiti logo new – Teniola Olowoporoku | Gender and Energy Compact](https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/4GZfA-6KmcKMq2HwscjvHSzXaSAohxsvXw4AQsMofV7sE6JJCW-RVC0PZ852v8evm4NQMOBIbfSN-6GADetmSldvj1AHWS5yTB7VQJg3p-faHw982dPsA1qiX2KTMrzx6mIYtL6eGY-7WdAvemsIZJQvrsAO_ayeV_OwTKgpLWMqLK2sz-j6xWR1Wb68xVCn?purpose=fullsize)

NEITI — solid minerals and petroleum audits

Use these records to reconcile reported production, company payments, royalties, federal receipts and discrepancies.

[Solid-minerals audit reports](https://www.neiti.gov.ng/audits/solid-minerals?type=main&utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com)

[Oil-and-gas audit reports](https://www.neiti.gov.ng/audits/oil-and-gas?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com)

![Nigeria Governors' Forum (@NGFSecretariat) on X](https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/bE1YiqJpH3CgMrCxIgicJwteOK_1L_SDT012DyWa4TI_wNSqLU3yvdGBZeN6rcjH5fYY9L2Y--IQCWKj_f5oE61NUnEJp53O0gn5FCqKkOx9l24UVtzXBDdAobNy1AHo03DIMHM6Wh_6VNqpJ1jgagoyA7GBQmxz41oTBOzSTgybrI3oye5Iar7FiAzCJkBj?purpose=fullsize)

Nigeria Governors' Forum — state fiscal accounts

Use actual state revenue, derivation, expenditure and debt figures to examine what each state received and how it spent the money.

[Open the Public Finance Database](https://publicfinance.ngf.org.ng/?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com)

![New Nigerian Online Mining Cadastre System based on GAF AG’s eMC+ officially launched, GAF AG, Story - PresseBox](https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/9f_eIqwVVO30O29R8t0ro7uyA93XXY_x6px5cAX7RTodlGAvSJvd_tlEnTDodm0SGAiTckP3MEtfVZ1UMgCTpaK7ml2R9JL9eOzLYfiU-r3SxYkTQtXgqkRPzXojojO9SLioajkCIoXaPtZZLVD7oFCI-U_WWq541w_oVQDPorf0XIiLMXqxmjbVgeDcrmDL?purpose=fullsize)

NEITI — solid-minerals data dashboard

Use the state and year filters to investigate reported mineral royalties, production and revenue by state.

[Open the minerals dashboard](https://dashboard.neiti.gov.ng/solid-mineral/index.php?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com)

### Conclusion: the evidence-based finding

The evidence establishes a genuine governance problem in Nigeria's solid-minerals sector, including illegal extraction, smuggling and weak revenue tracking. It also establishes that petroleum generates substantial national revenue while oil-producing communities continue to raise questions about environmental damage and the adequacy of local benefits.

It does not yet establish that the federal government deliberately applies a more permissive mining policy to the North because of ethnicity, or that all mineral wealth extracted from Ijaw territory has been withheld from the Ijaw people.

To establish or disprove unequal treatment, we need the same measures for each sector: production, licensing, revenue due, revenue collected, enforcement, transfers and actual community benefits.

That comparison—not assumption—will provide the basis for a defensible investigative newspaper report and a credible public demand for accountability.