5 min read

TAX THE PEOPLE, THEN ABANDON THEM?

KING’S COLLEGE, BAD ROADS AND THE DANGEROUS COLLAPSE OF NIGERIA’S SOCIAL CONTRACT

There comes a point in the life of a nation when citizens must stop asking only how much government wants from them and begin asking the more fundamental question:

What exactly is government giving back to the people?

That question has become unavoidable in Nigeria.

The government is aggressively pursuing taxation. It wants citizens, businesses and workers to pay more. It wants a broader tax base. It wants compliance. It wants every economic activity captured and taxed.

But where is the corresponding public service?

Where are the good roads?

Where are the functioning public hospitals?

Where are the reliable public schools?

Where are the drainage systems?

Where is the effective security?

Where is the social protection?

Where is the clean environment?

Where is the infrastructure that should make taxation meaningful to the ordinary Nigerian?

The Nigerian Constitution provides the starting point. It declares that the security and welfare of the people shall be the primary purpose of government.

That is not a political slogan.

It is a constitutional statement of purpose.

And it raises a fundamental question: can government continually demand more from citizens while delivering less to them?

KING’S COLLEGE HAS BECOME A SYMBOL

The controversy surrounding King’s College, Lagos, has therefore touched a much deeper nerve than the fate of one school.

The Federal Government says it has not sold King’s College. It says legal ownership remains with government and that the King’s College Old Boys’ Association will finance, rehabilitate, modernise, operate and maintain the institution under a public-private partnership. Government also says it will retain regulatory and oversight powers.

Those assurances deserve to be tested against the actual concession agreement and its implementation.

The proposed arrangement is reported to run for 25 years.

And this is where Nigerians must ask difficult questions.

If government owns an institution but cannot adequately maintain it, why?

If government has been collecting taxes for decades, why are public institutions deteriorating?

If government now needs private organisations to rehabilitate public schools, what happened to the billions of naira appropriated for education over the years?

If the private partner is expected to provide the money, what exactly does government contribute?

And most importantly:

What does the Nigerian taxpayer receive in return?

These questions are not an attack on the King's College Old Boys' Association.

Indeed, alumni intervention in public institutions can be valuable.

The real issue is the responsibility of the state.

GOVERNMENT CANNOT OUTSOURCE ITS CONSTITUTIONAL DUTY

A government may concession the management of an asset.

It cannot concession away its responsibility to the citizen.

That distinction must never be lost.

If private individuals rehabilitate King’s College, Nigerians should welcome investment that genuinely improves education.

But the government must remain accountable for the public education system.

The state cannot say:

«“We own the school, but we cannot maintain it.”»

Then say:

«“Private people should take over because government cannot do the job.”»

And simultaneously tell the ordinary citizen:

«“Pay your taxes.”»

That is where the social contract begins to look dangerously one-sided.

TAXATION WITHOUT PUBLIC VALUE?

The Nigerian citizen is increasingly surrounded by taxes, levies, duties, charges and fees.

The worker pays PAYE.

The consumer pays VAT.

Businesses pay various taxes and statutory charges.

Importers pay customs duties.

Motorists encounter multiple vehicle-related charges.

Property owners face various rates and levies.

Small businesses face numerous regulatory payments.

And yet the same citizen can leave home in the morning and encounter roads that are barely passable.

Gullies consume streets.

Flooding destroys property.

Drainage systems collapse.

Public hospitals struggle.

Schools deteriorate.

Electricity remains a major burden.

Security remains a daily concern.

Then government comes back with another tax drive.

Enough questions must now be asked.

Taxation is legitimate.

But taxation without accountability is dangerous.

Taxation without transparency breeds distrust.

Taxation without visible public value breeds resentment.

And taxation alongside the continuous transfer of public responsibilities to private hands raises an even more uncomfortable question:

What exactly is the government for?

LOOK AT CANADA

Consider the contrast with countries that operate stronger social-service systems.

Canada, for example, operates the Canada Child Benefit, which provides eligible families with monthly financial support based substantially on family circumstances and income.

Its healthcare system is publicly financed through taxation, although the system itself has limitations and provincial differences.

The principle is nevertheless clear:

Citizens contribute to the public purse, and the public purse finances services and social programmes.

That is what gives taxation a social purpose.

The Nigerian citizen deserves the same fundamental principle—not necessarily the Canadian model, but the principle that public revenue must translate into public value.

WHAT HAPPENED TO OUR ROADS?

Walk through Nigerian cities.

Drive through the streets.

Look at the gutters.

Look at the erosion.

Look at the abandoned projects.

Look at the potholes.

Look at the communities where residents contribute their own money to repair roads that government should have maintained.

Then ask those same citizens to pay more taxes.

It becomes difficult to explain the logic.

Government should not merely be a revenue-collection machine.

Government exists to convert public resources into public goods.

That is the essence of the social contract.

KING’S COLLEGE MUST NOT BECOME A PRECEDENT FOR GOVERNMENTAL ABDICATION

There is nothing inherently wrong with public-private partnerships.

But there is everything wrong with a system in which government gradually retreats from essential public responsibilities because it has failed to manage them properly.

Today it is King’s College.

Tomorrow another school.

Then another hospital.

Then another public utility.

Then another public asset.

Eventually citizens may wake up to discover that the government owns the assets on paper but private operators control most of the services citizens need—and citizens are still paying taxes to the same government.

That is the question Nigerians must confront before such a model becomes normal.

THE TWO-WEEK PAUSE MUST BE USED FOR TRANSPARENCY

The Federal Government has now paused implementation of the King’s College arrangement for two weeks and established a seven-member committee to review the agreement following the protests.

This pause should not merely be used to calm tempers.

It should be used to open the books.

Publish the agreement.

Publish the financial obligations.

Publish the investment commitments.

Publish the performance indicators.

Publish the duration.

Publish the government's obligations.

Publish the concessionaire's obligations.

Explain what happens to school fees.

Explain what happens to teachers.

Explain what happens if the concessionaire fails.

Explain how government will enforce the contract.

And explain, in plain language:

What does the Nigerian taxpayer gain?

That is the question.

GOVERNMENT MUST STOP TELLING CITIZENS ONLY WHAT THEY OWE

Nigeria cannot build a stable society by constantly telling citizens what they owe government while refusing to demonstrate what government owes citizens.

Citizens owe the state lawful taxes.

But government owes citizens security, accountability, infrastructure, justice, education, public health and responsible administration.

The Constitution itself puts the welfare and security of the people at the heart of government.

Therefore, when the roads collapse, citizens have a right to ask questions.

When schools deteriorate, citizens have a right to ask questions.

When public hospitals fail, citizens have a right to ask questions.

When public assets are concessioned, citizens have a right to ask questions.

When taxes increase, citizens have a right to ask questions.

And when government says:

“Pay more,”

the citizen has every democratic right to respond:

“Show us what you have done with what we already paid.”

That is not rebellion.

That is accountability.

THE NIGERIAN SOCIAL CONTRACT NEEDS REPAIR

The crisis before Nigeria is therefore bigger than King’s College.

It is about whether government still understands that public office exists to serve the public.

It is about whether taxation is going to remain merely a mechanism for extracting money from an already struggling population—or become part of a genuine social contract.

It is about whether government will continue to blame citizens for inadequate tax compliance while citizens watch public infrastructure decay around them.

And it is about whether Nigeria can build a system where taxation, accountability and public service are inseparable.

King’s College should therefore become a national test.

Not a test of whether the Old Boys Association can manage a school.

Not a test of whether government can sign a concession agreement.

But a test of something much bigger:

CAN THE NIGERIAN STATE STILL JUSTIFY WHAT IT COLLECTS FROM ITS CITIZENS BY WHAT IT DELIVERS TO THEM?

Until that question is answered convincingly, every new tax demand will inevitably provoke another question from the Nigerian street:

“Government, after taking our money, what exactly are you giving us?”

Type at least two letters to search titles, summaries and topics.