SPECIAL INVESTIGATIVE REPORT | PUBLIC FINANCE & CITIZENS' WELFARE
An international comparison of taxation, minimum wages, healthcare, purchasing power and the responsibilities of government.
By Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic (1992–1993)
Nigeria's growing emphasis on tax collection raises a fundamental question that deserves an answer from President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, the Federal Ministry of Finance, the National Assembly and the country's revenue authorities:
What is the justification for comparing Nigerian taxpayers with Europeans without comparing the services their governments provide?
Taxation is a legitimate responsibility of citizenship. It finances the institutions and infrastructure on which a modern society depends.
But taxation is only one side of the relationship between citizens and the state. The other side is public accountability, security, healthcare, infrastructure and the responsible use of public revenue.
A Nigerian worker earning the statutory minimum wage of ₦70,000 a month may struggle to purchase enough petrol to fill a vehicle's fuel tank. The same worker must pay for food, housing, transportation, medicines, education and other necessities.
The government must recognise that the capacity to pay taxes is determined not merely by nominal income, but by what remains after the unavoidable costs of living have been met.
This investigation examines the economic reality behind that principle.
1. The international evidence: What workers earn
The following table uses statutory minimum-wage rates in effect in October 2026. The figures are gross wages before applicable deductions, and the monthly calculations use each country's relevant working-time convention.
| Country | Statutory minimum wage | Approximate gross monthly earnings |
|---|---|---|
| Nigeria | ₦70,000/month | ₦70,000 |
| United Kingdom, age 21+ | £12.71/hour | £2,203 at 40 hours/week |
| Germany | €13.90/hour | €2,409 at 40 hours/week |
| France | €12.31/hour | €1,867 at 35 hours/week |
Sources: UK Government, German Federal Ministry of Labour, France Travail and Nigeria's statutory minimum-wage framework.
These numbers should not be compared simply by converting them into naira. Rent, energy, food, transport, taxes and living costs differ substantially across countries.
The more meaningful question is what a worker can afford after paying for essential needs, and which of those needs are already financed through public services.
2. What the wage comparison reveals
Illustrative gross monthly earnings in local currency
Each bar shows a percentage of its country's own stated monthly amount; bar lengths are not a comparison of purchasing power.
Nigeria
₦70,000
United Kingdom
£2,203
Germany
€2,409
France
€1,867
The difference in nominal wages is striking, but nominal figures alone do not establish how much better off a household is.
For a rigorous purchasing-power comparison, government should publish standard household budgets showing how much of a minimum wage remains after rent, transport, food, energy and healthcare.
Nigeria's challenge is especially severe because many households purchase essential services privately in addition to meeting their ordinary living expenses.
3. Healthcare: The most revealing evidence
Nigeria's healthcare financing burden
71.9%
of total current healthcare spending came directly from patients and households in 2023.
Out-of-pocket spending
Other financing
WHO health expenditure data, reported by the World Bank; latest available year in the retrieved series: 2023.
This figure should alarm every responsible Nigerian public official.
It does not mean that every Nigerian pays 71.9% of every hospital bill. It means direct household payments accounted for 71.9% of national current health expenditure.
That distinction matters, but the implication remains grave: Nigeria's healthcare system places an unusually heavy financing burden on households.
A worker suffering a medical emergency may face the choice between obtaining treatment and meeting basic family needs.
In the United Kingdom, the National Health Service provides a broad range of healthcare services without charges at the point of use, although exceptions exist. Germany operates compulsory health insurance through statutory and private arrangements, while France combines statutory health insurance with supplementary coverage.
European healthcare is not literally free: it is financed through taxation, insurance contributions and, in some cases, patient payments.
The essential difference is that these systems provide substantially more structured financial protection against medical costs.
Before government asks Nigerians to contribute more revenue, it should explain how it intends to reduce the extraordinary amount households already spend to obtain medical treatment.
4. Nigeria's tax reforms: What the law actually says
A fair investigation must acknowledge that Nigeria's tax legislation effective from 1 January 2026 contains provisions intended to protect lower-income taxpayers.
The reforms include:
- Exemption from personal income tax for individuals earning the statutory minimum wage or less.
- A zero-percent personal income tax band on the first ₦800,000 of annual chargeable income.
- Zero-rated or exempt treatment for several essentials, including specified basic foods, medical services, pharmaceutical products and education services.
- Reliefs and exemptions for qualifying small businesses.
These measures are described in the Presidential Committee on Fiscal Policy and Tax Reforms' published guidance.
It would therefore be inaccurate to claim that the new laws impose a flat 25% income tax on every Nigerian, or that a worker earning exactly the statutory minimum wage must pay personal income tax.
Nevertheless, an income-tax exemption does not eliminate the financial burden of living in an economy where households must privately finance essential services.
The correct test of tax reform is not simply whether its provisions look attractive on paper. It is whether implementation improves household welfare, reduces arbitrary levies, strengthens economic productivity and makes public expenditure more accountable.
5. What Nigerians should receive in return for taxation
| Public obligation | Nigeria's challenge | European comparison |
|---|---|---|
| Healthcare | High household out-of-pocket spending | Broader public or compulsory insurance coverage |
| Electricity | Households and businesses often rely on private generators | More dependable grid-based electricity |
| Roads | Poor maintenance raises transport costs | More extensive maintained transport infrastructure |
| Security | Insecurity disrupts farming, trade and movement | Generally stronger institutional protection |
| Education | Many families incur substantial private education expenses | Extensive publicly funded schooling |
| Social protection | Limited coverage and adequacy | More established unemployment, sickness and pension benefits |
The comparison is not an assertion that every European public service works perfectly. European countries face housing shortages, waiting lists, taxation controversies and public spending pressures.
The distinction is the extent to which taxpayers can rely on collectively financed services.
For example, the UK formally guarantees access to NHS services largely free at the point of use. Germany's statutory health insurance has a 14.6% general contribution rate plus supplementary contributions, while France reports that its public health insurance covers approximately 80% of healthcare expenditure.
6. The fuel-tank test: How much of a Nigerian salary goes into petrol?
The minimum-wage comparison becomes especially vivid when measured against the cost of petrol.
Calculate the fuel burden
Illustrative calculation using Nigeria's ₦70,000 monthly minimum wage. Change the petrol price and tank capacity to reflect your circumstances.Petrol price per litre (₦)
Fuel tank capacity
50 litres
Cost of one full tank
₦65,000
Share of monthly minimum wage
92.9%
Salary remaining after filling one tank: ₦5,000
The ₦1,300 starting price is an illustrative assumption, not a verified national pump-price average. This calculation excludes all other household expenses.
A country where one tank of petrol can consume almost an entire minimum wage must be extremely careful about the cumulative effect of taxes, levies, transport costs and energy prices.
7. Ten questions President Tinubu and the National Assembly must answer
- How much additional revenue has been collected since petrol subsidy removal, and how has it been spent?
- What measurable improvements in healthcare, roads, electricity and security can be attributed to that revenue?
- How much of Nigeria's public revenue goes into direct service delivery compared with administrative and debt-servicing costs?
- How many Nigerians have gained effective financial protection through public health insurance?
- What proportion of minimum-wage income is required to meet essential household expenses?
- How many kilometres of federal roads have been rehabilitated, with independent verification of quality?
- What measurable improvements have occurred in electricity supply to households and businesses?
- What programmes are restoring safe agricultural production in communities affected by insecurity?
- What mechanisms will prevent unlawful multiple taxation and harassment of small businesses?
- Will the government publish an annual, independently reviewed Taxpayer Benefits Report showing what citizens received for public money collected?
These questions should form the basis of a public hearing and a transparent national debate on fiscal accountability.
8. A proposed Nigerian Taxpayer–Government Social Contract
Nigeria needs a measurable framework connecting tax collection with public service delivery.
I propose that the Federal Government and state governments publish an annual scorecard covering five indicators:
01
Healthcare protection
Percentage of healthcare spending paid directly by households
02
Minimum-wage purchasing power
Cost of a standard household basket relative to monthly earnings
03
Infrastructure delivery
Verified road conditions, electricity reliability and water access
04
Security and food production
Safe access to farmland, displacement and agricultural output
05
Revenue accountability
Taxes collected, expenditures made and independently verified outcomes
Such a scorecard would allow Nigerians to judge whether increased government revenue produces corresponding improvements in living standards.
It would also create a basis for evaluating successive governments using evidence rather than political promises.
9. The constitutional obligation of government
Section 14(2)(b) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria provides that the security and welfare of the people shall be the primary purpose of government.
That principle is fundamental to the relationship between citizens and public institutions, even though the enforceability of Chapter II's directive principles is constitutionally limited.
The President, governors, ministers and legislators must remember that revenue mobilisation is a means to an end, not an end in itself.
A government does not become successful merely because it collects more taxes.
It becomes successful when public resources translate into safer communities, healthier citizens, better infrastructure, greater productivity and improved living standards.
10. Final message: The Nigerian taxpayer deserves dignity
Mr President,
Do not ask Nigerians to admire the tax systems of Britain, Germany and France without also examining the public services financed by those systems.
Do not compare revenue collection without comparing household welfare.
Do not celebrate rising government receipts while ordinary workers struggle to afford transportation, medical treatment and adequate food.
And do not confuse the ability to impose a tax with the economic capacity of citizens to bear its burden.
The Nigerian worker is not merely a source of government revenue. The Nigerian worker is a human being entitled to dignity, security and a reasonable standard of living.
We must build a tax system that encourages production, rewards enterprise, protects vulnerable households and holds public officials accountable.
The Nigerian people deserve more than repeated appeals for sacrifice.
They deserve measurable results.
“Before you tax Nigerians like Europeans, first give Nigerians the public services, protection and accountability that European taxpayers expect from their governments.”
— Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano
Research note: Figures are based on published official sources available as of 21 October 2026. The wage comparison is verified, but a full cross-country after-tax purchasing-power calculation would require harmonised household expenditure, housing and energy-price datasets. No unsupported purchasing-power ranking is asserted here.