6 min read

NIGERIA'S DOUBLE STANDARD IN RESOURCE CONTROL?

SOLID MINERALS IN THE NORTH, OIL IN THE NIGER DELTA: WHO REALLY BENEFITS FROM THE NATION'S NATURAL WEALTH?

INVESTIGATIVE FRONT-PAGE SPECIAL

From the gold fields of Zamfara to the lithium deposits of the North-Central, and from the oil wells of Bayelsa to the creeks of Rivers State, a troubling question demands a national answer: WHO CONTROLS NIGERIA'S NATURAL WEALTH, WHO COLLECTS THE MONEY, AND WHO PAYS THE PRICE?

By the Investigative Desk

Nigeria is a federation rich in natural resources but divided by a persistent argument over ownership, control, revenue and fairness. Beneath its soil lie gold, lithium, tin, limestone and other commercially valuable minerals. Beneath the creeks and coastal waters of the Niger Delta lies petroleum that has sustained a substantial part of the nation's public finances for decades.

Yet the people living closest to these resources continue to ask whether the benefits of extraction are distributed fairly—and whether the laws governing the country's mineral wealth are enforced consistently.

The question is particularly urgent for the Ijaw people of the Niger Delta, whose homeland has experienced extensive petroleum extraction, environmental degradation, oil spills, insecurity and prolonged disputes over resource control.

The controversy is not simply about North versus South. It is about whether Nigeria's federal system operates according to one transparent standard or whether different resource-producing communities experience markedly different realities.

THE SOLID-MINERALS QUESTION: WHO IS WATCHING THE MINES?

A report released by the Nigeria Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (NEITI) in May 2026 raised serious concerns about illegal mining, smuggling, opaque ownership, weak coordination among regulators and revenue losses in Nigeria's solid-minerals industry.

According to reporting on the NEITI policy brief, the sector contributed approximately ₦401 billion in revenue and 0.72 per cent of GDP in 2023. The watchdog also highlighted the extensive role of informal artisanal and small-scale mining, including serious regulatory problems in parts of the North-West.

The report described a system in which minerals can be extracted, traded, mixed with legally sourced material and moved through supply chains in ways that make production and financial flows difficult to trace.

These are not trivial administrative shortcomings. They raise fundamental questions about the capacity of government to know what is being extracted, identify who owns the businesses involved, collect royalties and taxes, and prevent mineral wealth from disappearing into opaque commercial networks.

The federal government has not entirely ignored the problem. In February 2026, the Minister of Solid Minerals Development reported that the government had registered 388 mineral-buying centres in 2024 and prosecuted 150 illegal miners. Those enforcement measures demonstrate activity, but they do not establish that illegal mining has been brought under control.

The contradiction is stark: Nigeria possesses considerable mineral wealth, yet the country continues to struggle to convert that wealth into transparently recorded public revenue and measurable improvements in the lives of mining communities.

BUT IS NORTHERN MINING LEGALLY FREE?

This is where the argument must be precise.

The Nigerian Minerals and Mining Act 2007 does not give every individual an unrestricted right to mine solid minerals simply because deposits exist on their land or within their community. Mineral exploration and commercial exploitation require the relevant legal authority.

The same federal government that controls petroleum resources also controls the solid-minerals licensing framework.

Therefore, the evidence does not support a blanket claim that northern Nigerians are legally permitted to mine freely while Ijaw people are legally prohibited from extracting their own petroleum.

The more serious question is whether federal authorities enforce the law effectively and consistently, and whether the financial and environmental obligations imposed on operators produce comparable accountability.

If unlicensed mining continues on a substantial scale in certain mineral-producing areas despite the law, the government must explain why its enforcement system has failed to stop it, identify the officials and commercial interests responsible, and disclose the revenue lost.

The public deserves to know whether illegal operators are evading oversight because of inadequate capacity, corruption, insecurity, political protection or a combination of these factors. Those possibilities require evidence, not assumptions about an entire ethnic group.

THE IJAW CONTRADICTION: OIL WEALTH WITHOUT SUFFICIENT LOCAL CONTROL?

For the Ijaw and other Niger Delta communities, the grievance is older and deeper.

Petroleum has been administered within a federal framework in which the central government exercises extensive control over licensing, production regulation and public revenue. Oil-producing states receive derivation revenue under the constitutional framework, but this does not amount to direct ownership and control of every barrel produced in their territories.

The 13 per cent derivation principle is an important part of this arrangement. Yet the existence of derivation payments does not automatically demonstrate that individual oil-producing communities have received adequate infrastructure, environmental remediation, employment or public services.

A 2019 report by The Guardian examined more than ₦10 trillion in derivation revenue received by oil-producing states over the period from 2000 to 2018 and questioned why many oil-producing communities remained without adequate roads, potable water, health facilities and other basic amenities.

That historical report raised a critical accountability issue: substantial revenue can reach a state government without necessarily producing visible improvements in every community from which the wealth originates.

This is why the investigation must follow the money beyond the federal allocation table. It must establish how much each state received, what it spent, which projects were completed, what contracts were paid for, and whether affected communities obtained the benefits promised to them.

ONE COUNTRY, TWO RESOURCE ECONOMIES—AND A COMMON ACCOUNTABILITY TEST

The comparison between northern solid minerals and Niger Delta petroleum must not be reduced to an unsupported claim that one region is permitted to take wealth while another is denied it.

The legal starting point is that both sectors are subject to federal control. The practical questions, however, differ.

In solid minerals, the challenge includes informal extraction, smuggling, unrecorded production, opaque ownership and the collection of royalties and taxes.

In petroleum, the challenge includes reconciling company payments with government receipts, verifying production, tracing derivation payments, accounting for deductions and establishing whether public revenue translates into development in producing communities.

NEITI's published oil-and-gas audits provide a basis for reconciling production volumes, company payments, government receipts and outstanding liabilities. Its solid-minerals audits provide a parallel starting point for examining licensing, revenue collection and regulatory enforcement.

The public should demand that the same standards of transparency apply to both.

Every licence should have a traceable owner. Every commercial extraction operation should have a verifiable legal status. Every royalty and tax due should be recorded. Every public allocation should be reconciled with receipts. Every environmental obligation should be monitored. And every allegation of official complicity should be investigated impartially.

THE QUESTION OF FEDERAL FAIRNESS

For the Ijaw people, the issue is not merely whether Nigeria has laws governing oil. It is whether those laws and the fiscal arrangements surrounding them have delivered a fair and sustainable relationship between the nation and the communities whose environment and resources bear the costs of production.

For mineral-producing communities in the North, the question is whether unregulated extraction and illicit trading deprive them and the wider federation of revenue, safety and environmental protection.

Both deserve lawful and transparent resource governance. Neither should be used as a justification for neglecting the other.

The federal government must publish comparable information on licences, production, revenue collection, enforcement actions and environmental compliance. State governments must account for the public money they receive. Operators must disclose their obligations and meet them. Regulators must explain the gaps between the law and what happens in the field.

OUR DEMAND: OPEN THE BOOKS

This investigation calls for a public, independently verifiable resource-accountability ledger covering:

  1. Solid minerals: mineral licences, beneficial owners, recorded production, exports, royalties, taxes, enforcement actions and revenue losses.
  2. Petroleum: field-level production where available, company payments, federal receipts, derivation allocations, statutory deductions and outstanding liabilities.
  3. Community benefits: funds received, projects approved, contractors paid, projects completed, environmental remediation and measurable local outcomes.
  4. Equal enforcement: comparable records of inspections, prosecutions, licence cancellations, penalties and recoveries across mineral-producing regions.
  5. Public accountability: audited annual reports identifying what was collected, what was transferred, what was spent and what remains unexplained.

THE FINAL QUESTION

Nigeria cannot credibly claim that its natural resources serve the common good if the public cannot trace the money from extraction to expenditure.

Nor can the nation settle the Niger Delta's grievances by merely announcing revenue allocations, without establishing whether the allocations are correctly calculated, promptly paid and converted into tangible benefits.

The question facing the federation is therefore bigger than whether northern solid minerals are mined more freely than Ijaw petroleum.

It is whether the Nigerian state can demonstrate, with transparent records, that the same principles of legality, accountability, environmental responsibility and public benefit govern every resource extracted from every part of the country.

Until those records are made accessible and independently reconciled, suspicions of unequal treatment will persist—and the people whose resources sustain the national economy will continue to demand answers.

The wealth is real. The laws exist. The missing test is transparent, verifiable accountability.

Source checks for publication

The article's central factual claims are supported by these published records:

  • NEITI's May 2026 warning on illicit financial flows in solid-minerals mining, including regulatory gaps, illegal extraction and revenue leakage. The Guardian Nigeria +1
  • Nigeria's Minerals and Mining Act 2007, covering federal control and the licensing requirements for mineral extraction. neiti.gov.ng
  • NEITI's 2021 oil-and-gas audit, documenting the revenue-sharing framework, derivation arrangements and outstanding liabilities owed to federal regulators. neiti.gov.ng
  • The Guardian's investigation into derivation revenue and conditions in oil-producing communities, published in November 2019. Nigeria and World News
  • The federal government's February 2026 announcement on oil-and-gas revenue remittances, relevant to the ongoing dispute over deductions and the Federation Account. The State House, Abuja

Editorial note: Before newspaper publication, the precise claim of unequal enforcement between northern mining communities and Ijaw oil-producing communities should be tested against comparable enforcement records. The article presents that issue as an investigation to be pursued, rather than a proven finding of ethnic discrimination.

Type at least two letters to search titles, summaries and topics.