SPECIAL INVESTIGATIVE EDITORIAL
Five local governments, armed groups at peace negotiations, proposed release of suspected bandits and communities still living in fear. Tinubu's government must explain where the boundary between negotiating peace and surrendering state authority lies.
By Our National Affairs Correspondent
ABUJA — Nigeria is facing a disturbing national security contradiction that demands urgent answers from President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, the Katsina State Government and the country's security establishment.
In Katsina State, negotiations with armed bandit groups have reportedly extended across several local government areas. What should ordinarily be an emergency effort to rescue communities from violence has developed into a major national debate about the authority of the Nigerian state.
How did Nigeria reach a situation where armed groups accused of killing, kidnapping, extorting and displacing citizens are sitting across negotiating tables with government representatives?
Who authorised the arrangements? What concessions have been made? Have the perpetrators surrendered their weapons? And what happens when those who have negotiated peace return to their guns?
These are not questions that can be dismissed as political opposition or social-media sensationalism.
They concern the survival of constitutional government and the protection of Nigerian citizens.
THE SHOCKING 70-SUSPECT RELEASE CONTROVERSY
Perhaps the most controversial aspect of the Katsina peace initiative emerged in January 2026.
The state government defended moves to facilitate the release of 70 persons suspected of involvement in banditry-related offences.
According to Commissioner for Internal Security and Home Affairs, Nasir Mu'azu, the peace arrangement covered at least 15 local government areas and had reportedly resulted in the release of approximately 1,000 abducted persons.
The government compared the proposed release to prisoner exchanges during wartime. Katsina govt +2
But this explanation raises a fundamental legal question.
When did Nigeria declare war on bandits in a manner that permits criminal prosecutions to be treated as bargaining instruments?
A person accused of kidnapping, murder or terrorism does not automatically become entitled to release because an armed group promises to free hostages.
Every suspect has constitutional rights. Every victim also has a right to justice.
The government must explain the legal basis for each proposed release, the role of the courts and whether individuals facing serious criminal charges were subjected to proper judicial procedures.
PEACE AGREEMENTS THAT DO NOT GUARANTEE PEACE
The danger of these arrangements became painfully evident when violence returned.
On February 10, 2026, Reuters reported that an armed gang killed at least 21 people in Doma, Katsina, after a six-month truce collapsed.
The agreement had reportedly involved the release of hundreds of kidnapped villagers and restrictions on weapons. A dispute following the killing of one of the gang's members triggered the retaliatory attack. Reuters
On September 22, 2026, PREMIUM TIMES reported renewed attacks, abductions and displacement in Katsina and neighbouring Sokoto despite local peace arrangements. Premium Times Nigeria
These developments expose the weakness of peace agreements that lack credible enforcement.
A government cannot celebrate the release of hostages while ignoring the possibility that the same armed networks may resume their criminal activities.
IS KATSINA BECOMING A STATE WITHIN A STATE?
The central issue is not whether government should negotiate. Governments negotiate in conflicts across the world.
The issue is whether Nigeria is allowing armed groups to acquire informal political and territorial authority.
When armed groups become powerful enough to influence access to markets, farms, roads and communities, the state must demonstrate that it remains in control.
No Nigerian citizen should need permission from a bandit commander to cultivate ancestral farmland or visit relatives.
No community should have to negotiate its right to exist with men carrying assault rifles.
And no government should confuse the temporary absence of gunfire with the restoration of law and order.
THE TINUBU GOVERNMENT MUST ACT
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu must urgently establish a comprehensive security framework for Katsina and the wider North-West.
This should include:
- Disarmament and verifiable surrender of weapons by armed groups seeking rehabilitation.
- Independent monitoring of every peace agreement.
- Prosecution of individuals implicated in serious crimes, subject to due process.
- Protection and compensation for victims of bandit attacks.
- Intelligence-led military and police operations against groups that refuse to surrender.
- Investigation of the financiers, arms suppliers and political protectors of criminal networks.
- Public disclosure of the results of peace agreements, including breaches and the consequences imposed.
The National Assembly must also investigate the relationship between state-level negotiations and the Federal Government's national security policy.
THE NNAMDI KANU QUESTION AND THE CRISIS OF EQUAL JUSTICE
The controversy has inevitably revived the debate over the detention and prosecution of Nnamdi Kanu.
The Federal Government must recognise that Nigerians are entitled to ask why different security challenges appear to attract different political and legal approaches.
But national security policy must not be reduced to an ethnic competition between the North and South-East.
The solution is not to abandon prosecution of legitimate offences. It is to ensure that the Constitution and the rule of law apply equally to everyone.
If the government can negotiate with armed criminals to save abducted Nigerians, it must also explain its approach to peaceful political dissent, separatist agitation and the protection of civil liberties.
The Nigerian state cannot afford the perception that justice has different standards for different regions.
OUR EDITORIAL POSITION
Katsina's suffering must not become a political weapon against its people. The ordinary residents of the state are not responsible for the crimes of armed groups terrorising their communities.
They deserve protection, not condemnation.
But the government must understand something fundamental:
A peace deal is not a substitute for sovereignty. A hostage exchange is not a substitute for justice. And a bandit who agrees to stop killing is not automatically a law-abiding citizen.
Nigeria must not reach a point where carrying weapons becomes a more effective way of negotiating with government than participating in democratic institutions.
The President must speak. Governor Dikko Radda must explain. The security agencies must account for their strategy. The courts must retain their independence.
The people of Katsina deserve peace, but they also deserve justice.
THE BIG QUESTION
IF ARMED GROUPS CAN SECURE NEGOTIATIONS, CONCESSIONS AND POSSIBLE RELEASES THROUGH VIOLENCE, WHAT MESSAGE IS NIGERIA SENDING TO THE NEXT GENERATION?
IS THE GOVERNMENT DEFEATING BANDITRY — OR MANAGING ITS PERMANENT PRESENCE?
WHY IS MNK MAZI NNAMDI KANU STILL IN THE SOKOTO PRISON:? NDIGBO I ASK.
Sources for this investigation: Reuters, PREMIUM TIMES, The Guardian, Channels Television and TheCable. The reported figures describe government statements and media investigations; they should not be interpreted as proof that entire local governments have been captured by bandits.