> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://uhlblog.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# FROM ₦100 DISPUTE TO FOUR YEARS IN PRISON: IS NIGERIA TURNING POLICE CRITICISM INTO A CRIME?
- URL: https://uhlblog.com/from-n100-dispute-to-four-years-in-prison-is-nigeria-turning-police-criticism-into-a-crime/
- Published: 2026-10-24T18:30:06.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-24T18:30:06.000Z
- Author: Dr. The Rt. Hon. Okechukwu Umeano

SPECIAL FRONT-PAGE INVESTIGATION | SATURDAY, 24 OCTOBER 2026

### 

Kaduna journalist's arrest, hurried Sharia court conviction and subsequent release on bail expose disturbing questions about police power, religious jurisdiction, freedom of expression and the future of constitutional democracy.

![الشرطة النيجيرية تنفي اختطاف 163 مسيحياً من قبل عصابات مسلحة](https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/C-XZVTFTpUV4LJPq_zh_cNyYGmNUq1YiZFpcgjt1FlFxXjAPBL8LTx27OanLSkzkkWccGR5CeSGzhqhIoN6p4onQAl33azt3UTz5P6meWf8e_ydqv3c4mfvwF1oasFKQjsdOUyPdcGvwR_rr-9V0D9WUAGrdfTXht2aFCZ_deC2WU5wm8U9dufMeEsATVCNt?purpose=fullsize)

Illustrative photograph of the Nigeria Police Force; not a photograph of the incident.

By Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic (1992–1993) | Pro-Democracy Advocate

### WHEN A CITIZEN CRITICISES THE POLICE, MUST SHE GO TO PRISON?

Something deeply troubling has happened in Kaduna State, Nigeria.

A disagreement involving just ₦100 reportedly escalated into the detention of a mother, the detention of her husband, the arrest of their journalist daughter and a four-year prison sentence imposed by a Sharia court.

The journalist, 23-year-old Farida Isiak of Nagarta Radio, had criticised the police on Facebook over their handling of her parents' situation.

According to investigations by PREMIUM TIMES and the International Centre for Investigative Reporting (ICIR), officers attached to Mararaban Jos Police Division subsequently detained her. The Divisional Police Officer, Usman Adamu, was identified in reports concerning the incident.

On 21 October 2026, she was brought before a Sharia court in Kawo, Kaduna, where she was initially sentenced to four years' imprisonment or a fine of ₦1.75 million.

Following intervention by lawyers, the conviction was set aside, she pleaded not guilty and was granted bail. Her case is scheduled to return to court on 3 November 2026.

But the reversal of that sentence does not erase the questions raised by the original proceedings.

How did a disagreement over ₦100 produce a criminal prosecution carrying such a severe penalty?

Why were members of the journalist's family reportedly detained?

Why was a journalist prosecuted after criticising the conduct of a public officer?

And why was the case brought before a Sharia court?

These are not questions for Kaduna State alone. They concern every Nigerian who believes that the police exist to protect citizens rather than intimidate them.

### THE ALLEGED USE OF PARENTS AS HOSTAGES

According to Farida's account, the dispute began with a disagreement between her mother and a neighbour over change from a charcoal transaction.

Police became involved, and her mother was arrested.

When her father went to secure his wife's release, he was also reportedly detained.

Farida subsequently published a Facebook post criticising the police response.

She alleged that the detention of her parents was used to pressure her into reporting to the police station. She further alleged that she was required to delete her Facebook post and apologise to the DPO.

She complied, but was nevertheless detained and prosecuted.

If these allegations are established, they represent an alarming abuse of police authority.

Section 36 of the Nigeria Police Act 2020 prohibits arresting a person merely in place of another person suspected of an offence.

The police cannot lawfully detain a father simply because they want his daughter.

They cannot lawfully detain a mother to compel her child to surrender.

Family relationships do not transfer criminal responsibility from one individual to another.

Nigeria must never become a country where a citizen's parents can be used as bargaining instruments to suppress criticism of government officials.

### FOUR YEARS IN PRISON FOR A FACEBOOK POST?

The initial sentence raises equally disturbing questions.

Farida acknowledged writing the Facebook post. But admitting authorship is not necessarily an admission of every legal element of a criminal offence.

Her lawyers challenged the initial proceedings, explaining that she had not properly understood the implications of her plea and had been convicted without legal representation.

The court subsequently set aside its earlier decision and permitted a fresh plea.

The Constitution guarantees every accused person the right to a fair hearing.

It also guarantees freedom of expression, although that freedom does not confer immunity from every legally established defamation claim.

Police officers have reputations deserving legal protection, just like other citizens. But public officials must also tolerate legitimate criticism of their performance.

There is a fundamental difference between maliciously publishing false allegations and expressing dissatisfaction with the conduct of a police officer.

A democratic society cannot survive when the boundary between criticism and criminality is determined by the anger of the person being criticised.

### WHY WAS A SHARIA COURT INVOLVED?

Perhaps the most constitutionally sensitive question arising from the incident is the decision to bring the journalist before a Sharia court.

Nigeria is a religiously diverse federation whose Constitution protects freedom of religion and prohibits discrimination on religious grounds.

Section 10 prohibits the federal and state governments from adopting any religion as a state religion.

Section 38 protects freedom of thought, conscience and religion.

Section 36 guarantees fair hearing before a court established by law.

Sections 275–279 provide for state Sharia Courts of Appeal, with constitutionally specified jurisdiction concerning Islamic personal law.

However, lower Sharia courts derive their jurisdiction from applicable state legislation, which must itself comply with the Constitution.

Therefore, the critical questions are whether the Kawo court had lawful jurisdiction over the alleged offence, whether the applicable criminal law authorised the prosecution, and whether the defendant's religious status was legally relevant.

The circulating audio claims that Farida is not Muslim. That particular assertion has not been independently verified in the reporting reviewed for this article.

It would therefore be irresponsible to declare, without evidence, that a non-Muslim was conclusively subjected to Islamic criminal jurisdiction.

Nevertheless, the court's jurisdiction must be publicly explained and legally scrutinised.

No Nigerian should be subjected to a criminal proceeding outside the lawful jurisdiction of the court hearing the case.

And no religious legal institution should be permitted to become an instrument for suppressing constitutionally protected criticism.

This is not an attack on Islam or on Muslims. It is a defence of constitutional safeguards that protect Muslims, Christians, traditional religion adherents and citizens of every other belief equally.

### THE POLICE MUST ANSWER THE QUESTIONS

The Kaduna State Police Command has disputed aspects of the public narrative.

Its spokesperson, Mansur Hassan, maintained that Farida's Facebook publication contained statements directed at the police, the DPO and other individuals.

However, the ICIR reviewed a screenshot of the publication and reported that the police account misrepresented aspects of its wording and whom particular remarks concerned.

The ICIR also observed that the police response did not adequately address why Farida's parents were detained or whether deleting the publication had been made a condition of their release.

These competing accounts require independent investigation.

The authorities should disclose the legal basis for every arrest, the precise charges, the relevant court records and the circumstances under which the initial conviction was set aside.

The accused police officers must have an opportunity to respond, but the investigation cannot credibly be left solely to the same officers whose conduct is being questioned.

### AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL AND THE JOURNALISTS' UNION SPEAK OUT

Amnesty International condemned the prosecution and called for the charges to be dropped.

It also demanded an independent investigation into the reported detention of Farida and her parents, warning against using criminal proceedings to punish journalists for criticism of the police.

The Nigeria Union of Journalists similarly expressed concern about the case.

The NUJ welcomed the journalist's release on bail but emphasised that bail alone does not resolve the underlying issues of liberty, fair hearing and press freedom.

It demanded a transparent investigation and proper scrutiny of the proceedings before the next hearing.

Both interventions deserve attention.

A country in which journalists fear imprisonment for questioning public officers is a country in which corruption, misconduct and abuse of authority become more difficult to expose.

### TODAY A JOURNALIST, TOMORROW AN ORDINARY CITIZEN

This incident should concern every Nigerian, irrespective of ethnicity, religion, political party or region.

Today, it is a journalist in Kaduna.

Tomorrow, it could be a trader in Onitsha, a student in Kano, a farmer in Benue, a teacher in Enugu or a civil servant in Lagos.

The danger is not confined to any one religion or geographical region.

The danger arises whenever an officer entrusted with public authority begins to treat criticism as personal rebellion.

Police uniforms do not confer immunity from public scrutiny.

A Divisional Police Officer is a public servant, not a monarch.

A police station is not a private detention facility.

A courtroom is not an instrument of personal vengeance.

And the Constitution is not a document that public officials may suspend whenever their feelings are hurt.

### WHAT THE INSPECTOR-GENERAL OF POLICE MUST DO

The Inspector-General of Police, the Kaduna State Commissioner of Police, the National Human Rights Commission and the relevant judicial authorities should ensure that this matter receives thorough scrutiny.

An independent investigation must determine whether Farida's parents were unlawfully detained, whether she was coerced into deleting her publication, and whether the police acted improperly in pursuing the criminal case.

The authorities should also review the precise charge, the statutory basis of the prosecution, the court's jurisdiction and the safeguards afforded to the defendant during the initial hearing.

Where misconduct is established, appropriate disciplinary or legal consequences must follow.

If unlawful detention or other violations are proved, the victims should have access to effective remedies, including compensation where warranted.

And the prosecution itself must be reviewed to determine whether it serves any legitimate public interest.

### A WARNING ABOUT THE NIGERIA WE ARE LEAVING TO OUR CHILDREN

I served in Nigeria's House of Representatives during the Third Republic, from 1992 to 1993.

I witnessed the struggle to establish and defend democratic government.

I understand that constitutional democracy is not sustained merely by conducting elections.

It survives when public officials accept limits on their authority.

It survives when citizens can criticise those who govern them.

It survives when courts act independently.

And it survives when police officers remember that the people they arrest are citizens with rights, not subjects without protection.

Our children must not inherit a Nigeria where the powerful are protected from criticism while the powerless are punished for speaking.

They must not inherit a country where a minor commercial disagreement can become an excuse for family detention and criminal prosecution.

They must not inherit a society where constitutional protections exist beautifully on paper but disappear at the police station.

The future of Nigeria depends not only on roads, electricity, hospitals or economic growth.

It also depends on whether an ordinary Nigerian can question a public official without fearing unlawful arrest.

### THE FINAL QUESTION: WHO PROTECTS THE CITIZEN FROM THE PROTECTOR?

Farida Isiak has been released on bail, and the initial conviction has been set aside.

That is an important development.

But her case remains unresolved.

The scheduled hearing on 3 November 2026 will be another test of whether the justice system can distinguish legitimate law enforcement from the alleged misuse of public power.

Nigeria must demand accountability without prejudging the final outcome.

The country needs professional police officers, independent courts, responsible journalism and equal constitutional protection for every citizen.

When a citizen criticises the police, the proper response is accountability—not retaliation.

When a court receives a criminal charge, its first duty is justice—not the protection of official pride.

And when the state exercises power over an individual, the Constitution must remain supreme.

The question before Nigeria is no longer simply what happened to Farida Isiak.

It is whether the institutions established to protect Nigerians can themselves be held accountable when they are accused of violating those protections.

A nation in which citizens fear their protectors is a nation whose democracy is in danger.

Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okey Umeano

Former Member, House of Representatives, Federal Republic of Nigeria (Third Republic, 1992–1993)

Editorial note: This article distinguishes documented court developments from allegations still requiring investigation. Farida Isiak's initial conviction was set aside, and she remains entitled to the presumption of innocence. The religious identity claim circulating in the original audio remains unverified.

Principal reporting: [ICIR investigation](https://www.icirnigeria.org/how-kaduna-court-jailed-journalist-for-four-years-after-posting-about-her-parents-detention/?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com) · [PREMIUM TIMES court update](https://www.premiumtimesng.com/news/more-news/919117-kaduna-journalist-granted-bail-after-court-sets-aside-conviction.html?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com) · [NUJ statement](https://www.radionigeriakaduna.gov.ng/2026/10/22/nuj-seeks-justice-for-detained-kaduna-journalist-farida-isiak/?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com)