How ethnic loyalty, political intimidation and the collapse of national solidarity are weakening democracy while millions of Nigerians struggle to survive.
By Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okechukwu David Umeano
Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic (1992–1993)
There is something profoundly disturbing about the state of democracy in Nigeria.
In France, citizens and civil society organisations can mobilise against the rising cost of living, government economic policies and deteriorating public services. Workers, students, pensioners and ordinary citizens can unite around their economic interests, irrespective of the ethnic or regional origins of their political leaders.
In Nigeria, however, a different political culture has taken root.
Petrol prices have risen dramatically. Food prices have devastated household budgets. Transport fares have become unbearable for many families. Businesses struggle with the cost of energy, while millions of citizens find it increasingly difficult to afford basic necessities.
Yet instead of developing a united national response to economic hardship, Nigerians are too often divided along ethnic, religious and political lines.
The tragedy is not simply that Nigerians are suffering. The greater tragedy is that citizens experiencing the same suffering are frequently encouraged to regard one another as political enemies.
WHEN AN IGBO MAN CRITICISES GOVERNMENT, WHY MUST IT BECOME AN ETHNIC WAR?
This is one of the most dangerous questions confronting Nigeria's democracy.
When an Igbo citizen criticises the economic policies of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, why should anyone interpret that criticism as hostility towards the Yoruba people?
When a Yoruba citizen questions the government, why should political loyalists accuse that person of betraying his ethnic community?
When a Hausa, Fulani, Ijaw, Tiv, Idoma, Ibibio or other Nigerian demands accountability, why should the person's ethnic origin matter?
The President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria is not the president of one tribe.
He is not elected to govern only those who share his language, religion or ancestral homeland.
He is constitutionally responsible to the entire federation.
Therefore, criticism of President Tinubu's government cannot legitimately be equated with hatred of Yoruba people.
Equally, criticism of any Igbo, Hausa, Fulani or other Nigerian political leader must never be treated automatically as hostility towards that leader's ethnic community.
A president is a public servant, not an ethnic possession. The presidency is a constitutional office, not an ancestral inheritance.
The moment Nigerians surrender that distinction, democracy begins to lose its meaning.
PETROL PRICES HAVE EXPLODED, BUT NATIONAL UNITY HAS COLLAPSED
Before the present administration, Nigerians were already struggling with rising fuel prices, inflation and declining purchasing power.
Following the removal of petrol subsidy on 29 May 2023, petrol prices increased sharply, with further increases and fluctuations subsequently affecting households and businesses.
The precise pump price varies by location and period, and reports of prices reaching ₦1,900 per litre require location-specific verification. But the economic burden of the increase is beyond dispute.
Consider what higher petrol prices mean for an ordinary Nigerian family.
The commercial driver must increase transport fares to remain in business.
The trader must pay more to transport goods.
The farmer must spend more moving produce to the market.
The schoolteacher must devote a larger share of a limited salary to transportation.
The hospital must pay more to operate generators.
The patient must pay more for medical services.
The student must struggle to afford transport to school.
And the unemployed young person must survive in an economy where even the cost of searching for work has increased.
These consequences do not recognise ethnic boundaries.
The petrol pump does not ask whether a customer is Igbo, Yoruba, Hausa or Fulani before dispensing fuel at the prevailing price.
Why, then, should Nigerians allow ethnic divisions to determine whether they can unite in demanding relief?
FRANCE SHOWS THAT CITIZENS CAN ORGANISE BEYOND THEIR DIFFERENCES
France is not a perfect democracy. Its recent protests have been accompanied by serious allegations of excessive police force, injuries and mass arrests.
Nevertheless, the French example illustrates something important: economic grievances can unite citizens across political and social divisions.
For Saturday, 17 October 2026, Yellow Vest activists, students and trade unions have called for demonstrations against rising living costs and deteriorating public services. French authorities have prepared for hundreds of protest actions.
In Nigeria, by contrast, economic hardship frequently becomes entangled with arguments over who should occupy the presidency.
We spend enormous energy defending politicians because they come from our regions, while paying insufficient attention to the consequences of their decisions.
What kind of democracy encourages citizens to defend the political privileges of their leaders while their own families struggle to survive?
WHERE ARE THE LABOUR UNIONS, STUDENTS AND CIVIL SOCIETY?
Nigeria was not always politically silent.
Our history records the resistance to military dictatorship, the struggles associated with the June 12 democratic mandate, the fuel subsidy protests of 2012 and the nationwide #EndBadGovernance demonstrations of 2024.
Nigerians have demonstrated that they can organise and demand accountability.
Indeed, in September 2026, public-sector unions threatened industrial action over petrol prices, wage demands and economic hardship.
Therefore, it would be inaccurate to suggest that nobody is resisting.
The more troubling question is why these efforts have not produced sustained, broad-based national cooperation capable of securing lasting economic reforms.
Where is the enduring alliance between organised labour, professional associations, students, market organisations, farmers and civil society?
Where is the common national platform that can demand affordable transportation, food security, accountable public expenditure and protection of fundamental rights?
These organisations do not have to agree on political parties, religion or constitutional restructuring to agree that citizens deserve economic dignity.
A GOVERNMENT MUST NEVER BECOME BIGGER THAN THE PEOPLE
Democracy is not merely the conduct of elections every four years.
It is a continuous relationship of accountability between the government and the governed.
When citizens become afraid to question government decisions, democratic institutions begin to lose their protective purpose.
When legitimate criticism is answered with ethnic insults, threats or intimidation, public debate is impoverished.
When political officeholders receive unquestioning loyalty because of their ethnic origins, public accountability suffers.
And when government supporters treat peaceful demonstrations as acts of hostility, the constitutional promise of democracy is undermined.
President Tinubu and his administration have the right to explain and defend their economic policies.
But Nigerians have an equally legitimate right to challenge those policies, demand evidence of their benefits and insist that the burdens of reform be fairly shared.
The government should publish clear accounts of subsidy savings, public borrowing, debt servicing, social interventions and measurable improvements in citizens' welfare.
The people are entitled to ask where the money is going.
THE REAL DANGER IS THE ETHNICISATION OF POVERTY
Perhaps the greatest political achievement of those who benefit from Nigeria's divisions is the transformation of common economic suffering into competing ethnic grievances.
Instead of asking why electricity remains unreliable, citizens quarrel over which region controls the presidency.
Instead of demanding better hospitals, they argue over the ethnic identities of ministers.
Instead of insisting that farmers return safely to their farms, they defend political parties whose security promises have not been fulfilled.
Instead of demanding affordable fuel, they exchange insults on social media.
This is how a country can possess enormous human and natural resources while struggling to build a common sense of national purpose.
But we must reject the suggestion that every Yoruba person supports President Tinubu, or that every Igbo person opposes him.
Such assumptions are themselves part of the problem.
There are courageous critics of government in every region, just as there are beneficiaries and defenders of political power across ethnic boundaries.
The real division that matters in public accountability is not Yoruba against Igbo, or North against South. It is between those who demand responsible government and those who believe political power should be protected from scrutiny.
NIGERIA NEEDS A NEW SOCIAL CONTRACT
The solution is not violence, ethnic confrontation or the destruction of public property.
It is the recovery of citizenship.
Nigerians must rediscover the principle that a citizen's constitutional rights do not depend on where the president comes from.
Peaceful demonstrations, lawful strikes, public-interest litigation, independent journalism, parliamentary oversight and credible elections must become instruments of accountability.
Government must also recognise that protecting peaceful dissent is not a favour to citizens. It is a constitutional obligation.
Nigeria needs a national economic conversation that transcends party loyalty and ethnic identity.
That conversation must demand concrete answers: How much has government saved from subsidy removal? How have those savings been spent? What has happened to real wages? What relief is reaching poor households? What measurable improvements justify the sacrifices demanded of citizens?
These are not ethnic questions.
They are questions of governance.
MY FINAL MESSAGE: HUNGER HAS NO TRIBE, AND POVERTY HAS NO RELIGION
As a former member of Nigeria's Third Republic House of Representatives, I understand that democracy was not handed to Nigerians without sacrifice.
Many citizens struggled, suffered imprisonment, lost opportunities and even died in the pursuit of democratic government.
It would be a profound betrayal of those sacrifices if democracy were reduced to the periodic election of leaders who could no longer be questioned.
The presidency belongs to the Federal Republic of Nigeria, not to an ethnic community.
The national treasury belongs to Nigerians, not to a political party.
And the right to peaceful protest belongs to every citizen, whether that citizen supports or opposes the government.
France's planned nationwide demonstrations should challenge us to examine the condition of our own democracy.
Not because France is without injustice.
Not because every French protest achieves its objectives.
But because citizens who disagree on many issues can still recognise a shared economic grievance and organise around it.
Nigeria must learn to do the same.
A hungry Yoruba child is not better fed because the president is Yoruba.
An unemployed Igbo graduate does not obtain employment merely because an Igbo politician condemns the government.
A struggling Hausa farmer does not become prosperous because a northern politician holds a powerful office.
What matters is whether government policies improve the lives of ordinary citizens.
That must become the standard by which every Nigerian government is judged.
History will not ask only who occupied Aso Rock.
History will also ask what the citizens did when their democracy was weakened, their living standards deteriorated and their country became increasingly divided.
And that brings us to the most uncomfortable question of all:
IF NIGERIANS CANNOT UNITE AGAINST HUNGER, POVERTY, INSECURITY AND INJUSTICE, WHAT EXACTLY CAN UNITE US AS ONE NATION?
Dr. (The Rt. Hon.) Okechukwu David Umeano
Former Member, House of Representatives, Third Republic (1992–1993) | June 12 Legislator err