8 min read

AFTER SUBSIDY REMOVAL, FOLLOW THE MONEY

BILLIONS BORROWED, MORE BILLIONS APPROVED: NIGERIANS DESERVE A FULL ACCOUNT OF EVERY DOLLAR

From Eurobonds to World Bank facilities, AfDB budget support and the Abu Dhabi financing deal, the central question is no longer whether Nigeria is borrowing. It is: How much has actually been received, where did it enter the Treasury, what was it spent on, and what did Nigerians get for it?

On 29 May 2023, President Bola Ahmed Tinubu announced the end of petrol subsidy, saying the resources would be redirected to infrastructure, education, healthcare and jobs. ("State House, 29 May 2023" (https://statehouse.gov.ng/))

More than three years later, Nigerians are entitled to ask:

If subsidy was removed to free government resources, why has borrowing remained so substantial—and where exactly has the borrowed money gone?

This is an accounting question, and accounting requires numbers.

CHRONOLOGICAL FACILITY LEDGER

Facility| Announcement date| Amount approved| Amount disbursed| Source| Current accounting status
$2.2 billion Eurobond| 2 December 2024| $2.20 billion| $2.20 billion raised| "Debt Management Office, Nigeria" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/)| Executed issuance; Treasury allocation and expenditure reconciliation not publicly established
AfDB EGET-SP Phase I| July 2024| $500 million| $500 million, fully disbursed in September 2024| "African Development Bank" (https://www.afdb.org/en/documents)| General budget support; Treasury receipt, allocation and expenditure trail requires publication
$2.35 billion Eurobond| 5 November 2025| $2.35 billion| $2.35 billion raised| "Debt Management Office, Nigeria" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/)| Executed issuance; proceeds reported for deficit financing and other government needs; detailed reconciliation not publicly established
First Abu Dhabi Bank financing programme| 2026| Up to $5 billion| $1.50 billion confirmed first drawdown| "Federal Ministry of Finance" (https://finance.gov.ng/); "First Abu Dhabi Bank" (https://www.bankfab.com/)| $3.5 billion programme capacity remains; allocation among refinancing, infrastructure and budget implementation requires disclosure
2025–2026 external borrowing plan| July 2025| $21.5 billion| Not established from the approval record| "Senate of the Federal Republic of Nigeria" (https://nass.gov.ng/)| Approval is not disbursement; individual facilities, drawdowns and possible overlap with other programmes require verification

The table distinguishes approvals from funds actually raised or disbursed. It should be updated as government publishes loan agreements, Treasury receipts, budget allocations, expenditure records and repayment schedules.

THE DEBT DID NOT DISAPPEAR

At 30 June 2023, shortly after President Tinubu assumed office, Nigeria's total public debt stood at ₦87.38 trillion, equivalent then to $113.42 billion. ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria Public Debt Stock as at 30 June 2023" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/debt-profile/total-public-debt))

That figure included ₦22.712 trillion in previously accumulated Central Bank Ways and Means advances that had been securitised. ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria Public Debt Stock as at 30 June 2023" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/debt-profile/total-public-debt); "National Assembly, Ways and Means securitisation legislation" (https://nass.gov.ng/))

It would therefore be misleading to attribute the entire June 2023 debt stock to the incoming administration.

The latest DMO report, published on 25 September 2026, covers Nigeria's debt position as at 30 June 2026. ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria Public Debt Stock as at 30 June 2026" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/debt-profile/total-public-debt))

Headline debt stock alone, however, does not tell the full story. It changes with new borrowing, repayments, exchange-rate movements and other adjustments. The more revealing exercise is to examine individual financing transactions.

$2.2 BILLION EUROBOND — MONEY ACTUALLY RAISED

On 2 December 2024, Nigeria returned to the international capital market and raised $2.2 billion: ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria, 2 December 2024 Eurobond issuance announcement" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/))

$700 million — 6.5-year Eurobond

$1.5 billion — 10-year Eurobond

The DMO's official records confirm the transaction. ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria, 2024 Eurobond transaction documents" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/)) This was money actually borrowed, not merely proposed or authorised. The key issue is how the proceeds were reflected in Treasury and budget financing and what expenditure they ultimately supported.

ANOTHER $500 MILLION — FULLY DISBURSED

The African Development Bank approved $500 million for Phase I of its Economic Governance and Energy Transition Support Programme in July 2024. ("African Development Bank, Economic Governance and Energy Transition Support Programme Phase I" (https://www.afdb.org/en/documents))

Its subsequent official appraisal document states that the entire amount was fully disbursed in September 2024. ("African Development Bank, EGET-SP I programme appraisal and completion documentation" (https://www.afdb.org/en/documents))

This was a General Budget Support Operation, not a $500 million power station or road contract. The relevant audit trail is:

AfDB → Federal Government budget → Treasury → expenditure and reforms.

Government should show how the fiscal resources created by the facility were accounted for.

THEN CAME ANOTHER $2.35 BILLION EUROBOND

On 5 November 2025, Nigeria raised: ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria, 5 November 2025 Eurobond issuance announcement" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/))

$1.25 billion maturing in 2036

plus

$1.10 billion maturing in 2046.

Total:

$2.35 BILLION

The respective coupons/yields were approximately 8.63% and 9.13%. ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria, 2025 Eurobond transaction documents" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/)) The DMO said the proceeds would finance the 2025 fiscal deficit and support other government financing needs. ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria, 2025 Eurobond issuance announcement" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/))

Again, this was general government financing, not a single identifiable road or other project. Treasury transparency is therefore essential.

$4.55 BILLION IN EUROBONDS ALONE

2024 Eurobond: $2.20 billion ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria, 2024 Eurobond transaction documents" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/))

2025 Eurobond: $2.35 billion ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria, 2025 Eurobond transaction documents" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/))

TOTAL: $4.55 BILLION

Adding the $500 million AfDB Phase I facility, documented as fully disbursed, brings the total to: ("African Development Bank, EGET-SP I programme documentation" (https://www.afdb.org/en/documents))

$5.05 BILLION

ENTER FIRST ABU DHABI BANK

In 2026, the Federal Government established a financing programme of up to $5 billion with First Abu Dhabi Bank through a Total Return Swap structure. ("Federal Ministry of Finance, Nigeria, FAB financing programme announcement" (https://finance.gov.ng/); "First Abu Dhabi Bank, transaction announcement" (https://www.bankfab.com/))

It would be inaccurate to say Nigeria had already received the entire amount. The government confirmed access to the first $1.5 billion tranche. ("Federal Ministry of Finance, Nigeria, FAB financing programme statement" (https://finance.gov.ng/))

The Finance Minister said the facility would refinance expensive debt, finance infrastructure and support budget implementation. ("Federal Ministry of Finance, Nigeria, FAB financing programme statement" (https://finance.gov.ng/))

The ledger is therefore:

Programme ceiling: $5 billion ("Federal Ministry of Finance, Nigeria, FAB financing programme announcement" (https://finance.gov.ng/))

Confirmed first drawdown: $1.5 billion ("Federal Ministry of Finance, Nigeria, FAB financing programme statement" (https://finance.gov.ng/))

Remaining programme capacity: $3.5 billion

The government should disclose how the $1.5 billion was allocated among refinancing, infrastructure and general budget implementation.

AT LEAST $6.55 BILLION WORTH FOLLOWING

The four major external financing streams with strong evidence of actual issuance or disbursement are:

2024 Eurobond — $2.20 billion ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria, 2024 Eurobond transaction documents" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/))

AfDB EGET-SP I — $500 million ("African Development Bank, EGET-SP I programme documentation" (https://www.afdb.org/en/documents))

2025 Eurobond — $2.35 billion ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria, 2025 Eurobond transaction documents" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/))

FAB confirmed first drawdown — $1.50 billion ("Federal Ministry of Finance, Nigeria, FAB financing programme statement" (https://finance.gov.ng/))

TOTAL: $6.55 BILLION

This is not the total amount borrowed by the Tinubu administration. It is a narrower figure covering four major financing streams for which there is strong evidence that money was raised or drawn.

THEN THERE IS THE $21.5 BILLION BORROWING PLAN

In July 2025, the Senate approved President Tinubu's $21.5 billion 2025–2026 external borrowing plan. ("Senate of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, external borrowing-plan approval records, July 2025" (https://nass.gov.ng/)) Additional authorisations included a Japanese-yen loan and authority to raise foreign-currency financing domestically. ("Senate of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, borrowing-plan approval records" (https://nass.gov.ng/))

But:

$21.5 BILLION APPROVED DOES NOT MEAN $21.5 BILLION RECEIVED.

A borrowing plan is not a disbursement. Individual loans must be identified and traced, especially since lawmakers indicated that disbursement could extend beyond a single fiscal year. ("Senate of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, borrowing-plan debate and approval records" (https://nass.gov.ng/))

Nor should the entire $21.5 billion be added to every World Bank, AfDB and commercial facility without checking whether they form part of the same programme. That would risk double counting.

FOLLOWING THE MONEY INTO THE TREASURY

The investigation therefore moved beyond announcements and approvals into federal budget and Treasury records.

Project-specific borrowing can often be traced through:

Lender → project → ministry → contractor → payment → physical work.

General budget financing is different. Eurobond proceeds may enter the overall financing pool, making it impossible to attribute a particular payment to a particular bond without government accounting records.

The Federal Government should publish that reconciliation.

WHAT THE PUBLIC LEDGER SHOULD SHOW

For every external financing facility contracted since 29 May 2023, Nigerians should be able to see:

LENDER

↓

AMOUNT APPROVED

↓

AMOUNT CONTRACTED

↓

AMOUNT ACTUALLY DISBURSED

↓

DATE RECEIVED

↓

CBN/TREASURY ACCOUNT

↓

NAIRA VALUE AND ACCOUNTING EXCHANGE RATE

↓

BUDGET LINE

↓

MINISTRY, DEPARTMENT OR AGENCY

↓

AMOUNT RELEASED

↓

PAYEE OR CONTRACTOR

↓

PROJECT OR PURPOSE

↓

LOCATION

↓

PHYSICAL COMPLETION

↓

AMOUNT REPAID

↓

OUTSTANDING DEBT

That is basic public accounting.

OUR TREASURY INVESTIGATION HAS BEGUN

The Federal Government's Budget Office maintains quarterly budget-implementation reports for 2023, 2024 and 2025, with additional 2026 records now available. ("Budget Office of the Federation, budget implementation reports" (https://budgetoffice.gov.ng/)) These allow comparisons among:

appropriation

revenue

borrowing

actual expenditure.

The next stage is an MDA-by-MDA review of the Ministries of Works, Power, Transportation, Marine and Blue Economy, Agriculture, Water Resources, Health, Education and Communications/Digital Economy.

For each, citizens should be able to establish:

How much was budgeted?

How much was released?

How much was paid?

Who received it?

For what contract?

Where is the project?

How much work has been completed?

And:

Can the payment be linked to a particular foreign loan?

DO NOT CONFUSE A BUDGET PAYMENT WITH A LOAN PAYMENT

If Treasury records show that the Ministry of Works paid a contractor ₦20 billion shortly after Nigeria raised a Eurobond, that does not prove the payment came from that Eurobond.

Correlation is not accounting evidence. Until the government provides a financing-to-expenditure reconciliation, the accurate entry is:

Treasury payment confirmed — specific loan attribution not established.

THE SUBSIDY QUESTION HAS NOT DISAPPEARED

President Tinubu said subsidy savings would support infrastructure, education, healthcare and jobs. ("State House, 29 May 2023 subsidy-removal address" (https://statehouse.gov.ng/)) Nigerians endured the economic consequences of the policy while the Federal Government continued accessing domestic and foreign financing.

The public therefore needs answers to two separate questions:

WHERE ARE THE SUBSIDY SAVINGS?

WHERE DID THE BORROWED MONEY GO?

THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY HAS A CONSTITUTIONAL OVERSIGHT ROLE

The legislature's responsibility should not end with approval. For every major borrowing authorisation, relevant committees should demand reports showing:

amount contracted

amount disbursed

interest and fees

repayment obligations

implementing MDA

projects financed

contractors paid

implementation percentage

and

measurable public results.

NIGERIANS DO NOT NEED SLOGANS — THEY NEED A LEDGER

Some borrowing refinances more expensive debt, some provides general budget support, some finances infrastructure, and some approved facilities remain partly or wholly undisbursed. These distinctions make accurate reporting more important, not less.

Government should publish a quarterly:

TINUBU ADMINISTRATION BORROWING AND DISBURSEMENT REGISTER — 29 MAY 2023 TO DATE

It should identify each facility's approval, contracting, drawdown, Treasury receipt, budget allocation, expenditure, project or purpose, repayment and outstanding balance.

It should not mix approvals with disbursements, count undrawn facilities as spent, or claim that a Treasury payment came from a particular loan without documentary evidence.

THE QUESTION BEFORE NIGERIA

Petrol subsidy was removed on the promise that resources would support national development. Yet substantial borrowing continued.

We have identified $4.55 billion in executed Eurobond issuance, $500 million in AfDB financing documented as fully disbursed, and a $1.5 billion confirmed first drawdown from the FAB financing programme. ("Debt Management Office, Nigeria, 2024 and 2025 Eurobond documents" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/); "African Development Bank, EGET-SP I documentation" (https://www.afdb.org/en/documents); "Federal Ministry of Finance, Nigeria, FAB financing statement" (https://finance.gov.ng/))

That is $6.55 billion across four clearly evidenced financing streams.

Beyond them are World Bank facilities, bilateral and multilateral loans, commercial arrangements, domestic bonds and broader borrowing authorisations that must be classified as approved, contracted, partially disbursed or fully drawn. ("World Bank, Nigeria financing and project documents" (https://projects.worldbank.org/en/projects-operations/projects-list?countrycode_exact=NG); "Debt Management Office, Nigeria, debt profile" (https://www.dmo.gov.ng/debt-profile))

Nigeria needs the books opened:

Publish the loan agreements.

Publish the drawdowns.

Publish the Treasury receipts.

Publish the budget releases.

Publish the contractors and beneficiaries where applicable.

Publish the projects and implementation levels.

Publish repayments and outstanding balances.

Then Nigerians can judge the record from the evidence.

The issue is no longer simply:

HOW MUCH HAS NIGERIA BORROWED?

The more important question is:

WHAT DID NIGERIA RECEIVE FOR THE DEBT THAT FUTURE GENERATIONS WILL HAVE TO REPAY?

Type at least two letters to search titles, summaries and topics.